A comparison of nitrous oxide and midazolam on cognition and mood

Key Points

• The ability of patients to perform skilled tasks is impaired with midazolam sedation, but not with nitrous oxide/oxygen sedation.

• Midazolam sedation produces enduring amnesia in the peri-operative period but nitrous oxide does not impair memory.

• Patients undergoing midazolam sedation should receive written post-operative instructions, which must prohibit them from undertaking skilled tasks until the drug has been completely eliminated from their body.

• Patients receiving nitrous oxide/oxygen sedation may resume their normal daily activities upon discharge.

Abstract

Objectives

To compare the effects of nitrous oxide and midazolam on cognition and mood.

Design

A three-way, counterbalanced, cross-over study, using patients receiving conscious sedation for routine dental treatment.

Methods

On each of three separate visits, patients performed a computerised test battery to determine baseline cognitive performance. Then, following administration of either midazolam, nitrous oxide, or no drug, patients re-performed the test battery. Finally, patients completed visual analogue scales assessing their subjective mood state.

Results

Relative to baseline performance, midazolam administration produced significantly slower reaction times compared with nitrous oxide and no-drug conditions. Furthermore, patients receiving midazolam were impaired in accuracy relative to the other conditions on many of the cognitive tasks, particularly those assessing the recall of information. Patient performance in nitrous oxide and control conditions did not significantly differ. These results could not be explained by differences in mood between the conditions, as subjective mood ratings during midazolam or nitrous oxide administration were very similar.

Conclusions

It is important for clinicians to be aware that peri-operative recall of information is reduced in patients who have undergone midazolam sedation. This is an advantage for patients who are anxious, and do not wish to be aware of the operative treatment being performed. However, as the cognitive impairment is enduring, an adult escort and written post-operative instructions should be mandatory for midazolam sedation patients. In contrast, the use of nitrous oxide sedation does not significantly impair higher cognitive tasks and thus patients receiving nitrous oxide sedation can resume normal activities in the post-operative period.

Log in or create a free account to read this content

Gain free access to this article, as well as selected content from this journal and more on nature.com

Access through your institution

or

Sign in or create an account

Continue with Google

Continue with ORCiD