Table 1 Characteristics of study participants at baseline

From: Genetic nurse counsellors can be an acceptable and cost-effective alternative to clinical geneticists for breast cancer risk genetic counselling. Evidence from two parallel randomised controlled equivalence trials

 

Grampian

Wales

 

Nurse counsellor

Geneticist

Nurse counsellor

Geneticist

No. of patients

193

96

197

100

Age (years): mean (s.d.)

40.7 (10.3)

41.4 (9.4)

39.8 (10.2)

39.0 (9.3)

Married/cohabiting: n (%)

151 (80.3)

74 (77.9)

161 (81.7)

84 (84.8)

With children: n (%)

157 (83.5)

73 (76.0)

157 (79.7)

73 (73.0)

Post-secondary education: n (%)

76 (39.4)

43 (44.8)

73 (37.1)

42 (42.0)

Referral source: n (%)

 General practitioner

133 (68.9)

63 (65.6)

117 (59.4)

56 (56.0)

 Breast surgeon

35 (18.1)

19 (19.8)

73 (37.1)

42 (42.0)

 Breast screening clinic

17 (8.8)

10 (10.4)

 Other

8 (4.1)

4 (4.2)

7 (3.5)

2 (2.0)

n (%) perceiving themselves to be at elevated risk at baseline

130/181a (72)

65/91a (71)

119/ 179b (83)

76/90b (84)

n (%) assessed at clinic at elevated risk

173/192c (90)

74/95c (78)

145/197d (74)

84/100d (84)

  1. For perceived risk, participants previously affected by breast cancer are excluded:
  2. aSeven nurse counsellor, one geneticist.
  3. b10 nurse counsellor, three geneticist.
  4. For assessed risk, participants previously affected by breast cancer are included:
  5. cFive nurse counsellor, one geneticist.
  6. d 10 nurse counsellor, three geneticist.