Table 4 Respondents indicating ‘Strongly Agree/ Agree’ with statements on causes of breast cancer, n (%)

From: Genetic nurse counsellors can be an acceptable and cost-effective alternative to clinical geneticists for breast cancer risk genetic counselling. Evidence from two parallel randomised controlled equivalence trials

 

Grampian

Wales

 

Nurse counsellor

Geneticist

P -value a

Nurse counsellor

Geneticist

P -value a

Stress is a major cause of breast cancer

 Baseline

68 (36)

40 (42)

 

68 (35)

34 (35)

 

 Immediately after episode

80 (47)

39 (48)

0.98

63 (38)

31 (37)

0.98

 Six months after episode

71 (42)

31 (44)

0.83

55 (37)

26 (36)

0.91

One close relative with breast cancer always increases your risk considerably

 Baseline

157 (83)

77 (81)

 

165 (84)

80 (83)

 

 Immediately after episode

127 (73)

52 (63)

0.12

130 (77)

65 (77)

0.99

 Six months after episode

123 (77)

56 (76)

0.97

122 (81)

58 (80)

0.88

Minor injury can cause breast cancer

 Baseline

37 (20)

20 (21)

 

62 (32)

23 (24)

 

 Immediately after episode

38 (22)

22 (27)

0.50

50 (30)

16 (19)

0.09

 Six months after episode

47 (29)

17 (23)

0.39

50 (33)

18 (25)

0.24

  1. aFrom χ2 test (Yates' corrected – for 2 × 2 table).