Table 4 Method of detection of all ipsilateral breast relapses in conservation surgery studies

From: Follow-up in breast cancer: does routine clinical examination improve outcome? A systematic review of the literature

 

Number of patients in study

Total number of patients with relapse

Patient detected

Mammographic

Clinical examination

Unknown or incidental

Mahoney, 1986

273

52

20 (38%)

1 (2%)

31 (60%)

0

Rutgers et al (1991)

44

44

26 (59%)

8 (18%)

10 (23%)

0

Jack et al (1998)

341

24

9 (37.5%)

9 (37.5%)

6 (25%)

0

Grogan et al (2002)

104

3

1 (33%)

2 (66%)

0

0

van der Sangen et al (2006)

3280

102

41 (41%)

32 (32%)

13 (13%)

16 (16%)

Montgomery et al (2007)

1312

48

17 (36%)

25 (52%)

4 (8%)

2 (4%)