Sir, I was very sad to read that John Bates had passed away earlier this year (BDJ 2007; 202: 701). Derek Stafford's words were very poignant and described so accurately the Prof Bates that this former student remembers.

I found myself smiling as I thought back to my undergraduate days and to this very special teacher. I was one of those 'who regarded him with affection'. Derek Stafford is absolutely right. We were in awe of him. But we also knew that he always had our welfare uppermost in his mind – even if we didn't necessarily deserve it. It was he who kindled and encouraged my interest in removable prosthodontics.

Having passed finals, I was unsuccessful in securing a house officer position. To my surprise Prof summoned me to his office, ascertained that I wanted to stay in hospital and said he'd see what he could do. The next morning I was in Birmingham attending for interview in the dental school.

Over the years, I am sure that I was just one of many he helped in a similar way, but I shall be forever grateful to him.

The profession is poorer for his loss.