Table 3 Patient outcomes following ‘unjustifiable’ alteration in surgical plans

From: Multidisciplinary decisions in breast cancer: does the patient receive what the team has recommended?

Original MDT decision

Actual treatment received

Comments

WLE

Mx

38 mm cancer (possibly borderline for WLE)

WLE

Mx

32 mm cancer (possibly borderline for WLE)

Duct clearance

Mx

Single stage therapeutic breast surgery

Mx

WLE

27 mm cancer with clear margins

Mx

WLE then cavity shave

2 operations to achieve clear margins

Mxa

Primary endocrine

Not reassessed for surgery

ALNDa

Primary endocrine

Not reassessed for surgery

ALND

SLNB then ALND

2-stage axillary surgery (positive SLNB)

SLNB

ALND

Positive ALND (4/20 nodes)

SLNB

ALND

Positive ALND (1/14 nodes)

SLNB

ALND

Negative ALND (0/8 nodes)

SLNB

ALND

Negative ALND (0/8 nodes)

SLNB

ALND

Negative ALND (0/40 nodes)

SLNB

No axillary surgery

DCIS only with no invasive breast cancer

  1. Abbreviations: ALND=axillary lymph node dissection; DCIS=ductal carcinoma in situ; MDT=multidisciplinary team; Mx=mastectomy; SLNB=sentinel lymph node biopsy; WLE=wide local excision.
  2. arepresents the same patient.