Table 4 Accuracy of sAxl, sAxl/albumin ratio, ELF™ test and transient elastography (Fibroscan®) for the detection of significant fibrosis (≥F2), advanced fibrosis (≥F3), F4 and cirrhosis according to imaging

From: The non-invasive serum biomarker soluble Axl accurately detects advanced liver fibrosis and cirrhosis

Fibrosis/cirrhosis

AUC (95%CI)

Sensitivity (%)

Specificity (%)

PPV

NPV

Youden's Index

Cut-off

sAxl

 All patients

       

F≥2

0.737

59.4

80.2

73.1

68.6

0.396

52.78

F≥3

0.749

70.5

74.0

51.5

86.5

0.445

52.78

F4

0.801

77.8

71.9

38.9

93.4

0.497

52.98

Cirrhosis

0.807

78.5

72.8

36.4

94.4

0.512

52.98

 NAFLD

F≥2

0.692

49.1

83.9

65.1

72.9

0.330

48.96

F≥3

0.747

62.2

86.7

60.5

87.5

0.489

52.78

F4

0.788

70.0

83.1

38.9

94.7

0.531

52.97

Cirrhosis

0.776

70.0

82.1

34.1

95.4

0.521

52.97

 Viral hepatitis

F≥2

0.697

69.1

67.7

79.2

55.3

0.368

54.01

F≥3

0.718

78.1

57.4

52.1

81.6

0.355

54.00

F4

0.788

71.4

80.0

53.6

89.7

0.514

65.32

Cirrhosis

0.788

71.4

80.0

53.6

89.7

0.514

65.32

 AIH/CLD/Overlap

F≥2

0.754

60.0

87.5

33.3

47.5

0.475

52.22

F≥3

0.640

60.0

67.9

50.0

76.0

0.279

60.32

F4

0.696

72.7

68.8

44.4

88.0

0.415

60.32

Cirrhosis

0.760

75.0

78.0

40.9

93.9

0.530

60.32

sAxl/albumin

 All patients

F≥2

0.763

54.4

88.1

81.3

68.3

0.425

1.29

F≥3

0.776

65.3

81.0

53.1

87.4

0.463

1.29

F4

0.826

77.8

78.5

46.2

93.9

0.562

1.29

Cirrhosis

0.831

78.5

79.5

44.0

94.9

0.580

1.29

 NAFLD

       

F≥2

0.712

61.4

78.5

63.6

76.8

0.399

1.03

F≥3

0.774

62.2

92.0

71.9

88.1

0.542

1.19

F4

0.798

65.0

92.3

56.5

94.5

0.573

1.36

Cirrhosis

0.789

65.0

91.4

50.0

95.2

0.564

1.36

 Viral hepatitis

       

F≥2

0.736

54.5

87.1

88.2

51.9

0.416

1.42

F≥3

0.750

53.1

90.7

77.3

76.6

0.439

1.69

F4

0.823

71.4

89.2

68.2

90.6

0.607

1.69

Cirrhosis

0.823

71.4

89.2

68.2

90.6

0.607

1.69

 AIH/CLD/Overlap

       

F≥2

0.750

60.0

87.5

95.5

33.3

0.475

1.22

F≥3

0.657

33.0

96.4

83.0

73.0

0.298

3.66

F4

0.739

63.6

75.0

46.7

85.7

0.386

1.60

Cirrhosis

0.805

75.0

79.7

42.9

94.0

0.547

1.47

ELF™test

 All patients

       

F≥2

0.819

75.4

76.4

73.7

77.9

0.517

9.2

F≥3

0.858

72.0

83.7

64.3

89.2

0.557

9.9

F4

0.909

89.1

78.4

46.6

97.4

0.675

9.8

Cirrhosis

0.909

87.5

78.9

42.4

97.4

0.664

9.8

 NAFLD

       

F≥2

0.831

77.4

80.7

70.7

85.5

0.580

9.2

F≥3

0.876

90.9

75.0

52.6

96.4

0.659

9.2

F4

0.929

93.8

84.8

44.1

99.1

0.785

9.7

Cirrhosis

0.936

93.8

86.3

42.9

99.2

0.801

9.7

 Viral hepatitis

       

F≥2

0.763

82.9

64.0

79.1

69.6

0.469

8.9

F≥3

0.792

56.5

90.7

76.5

79.6

0.472

10.2

F4

0.813

100

47.2

31.7

100

0.472

9.0

Cirrhosis

0.813

100

47.2

31.7

100

0.472

9.0

 AIH/CLD/Overlap

       

F≥2

0.747

50.0

100

100

33.0

0.500

10.8

F≥3

0.795

81.8

79.2

64.3

90.5

0.610

10.8

F4

0.872

100

80.8

64.3

100

0.808

10.8

Cirrhosis

0.898

90.0

88.5

60.0

97.9

0.785

10.8

Fibroscan®

 All patients

       

F≥2

0.850

67.0

86.0

77.3

77.9

0.524

9.4

F≥3

0.890

76.0

88.0

66.7

92.0

0.639

11.1

F4

0.970

88.0

95.0

75.0

98.0

0.834

16.6

Cirrhosis

0.930

84.0

96.0

76.2

97.3

0.799

16.6

 NAFLD

       

F≥2

0.853

81.8

74.5

58.1

90.5

0.563

8.9

F≥3

0.935

90.9

80.6

45.5

98.0

0.716

10.1

F4

0.935

100

78.5

36.4

100

0.785

10.1

Cirrhosis

0.937

100

79.1

36.4

100

0.791

10.1

 Viral hepatitis

       

F≥2

0.760

85.0

100

100

81.2

0.850

8.9

F≥3

0.887

92.3

75.0

70.6

93.8

0.673

8.8

F4

1.000

100

100

100

100

1.000

18.8

cirrhosis

1.000

100

100

100

100

1.000

18.8

 AIH/CLD/Overlap

       

F≥2

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

F≥3

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

F4

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

n.d.

cirrhosis

1.000

100

100

100

100

1.000

23.1

  1. Abbreviation: n.d., not determined