Table 1 Summary of prenatal findings, suspected diagnosis, exome-sequencing results, and final diagnosis

From: Rapid prenatal diagnosis using targeted exome sequencing: a cohort study to assess feasibility and potential impact on prenatal counseling and pregnancy management

Case

Gest

Ultrasound findings

Prenatal diagnosis

Fetal sequencing result

Inheritance

Classification

Outcome

Molecular diagnosis

Days to diagnosis a

1

25

Short leg bones; mild bowed femora

? Skeletal dysplasia

COL1A1 c.1168G>A p.(Ala390Thr) (het) NM_000088.3

Paternally inherited VUS

3b HGMD: CM090256

LB

None made; mild femoral shortening and bowing on postnatal radiographs

 

2

13.5

Progressive short limbs, small chest, short ribs

SRPS

WDR34 c.882G>C p.(Lys294Asn) (hom)NM_052844.3

AR Biparental inheritance

4b Novelc

ToP at 16 weeks; no PM

Short-rib thoracic dysplasia 11

30

3

12

NT 7 mm, flexion deformities of wrists with single forearm bones and bent humeri, short femurs, pleural effusions

? Skeletal dysplasia

RBM8A c.-21G>A (het) 484Kb deletion on 1q21.1 including RBM8A NM_005105.4

AR

5b ClinVar: RCV000081257.4; RCV000023418.9

LB; bilateral radial aplasia, aplastic humerus, fixed flexed wrists and right knee; severe thrombocytopenia

Thrombocytopenia absent radius syndrome

27

4

13.4

Micromelia, short ribs, unossification vertebral bodies

Lethal skeletal dysplasia ? achondrogenesis

COL2A1 c.1969G>C p.(Gly657Arg) (het) NM_001844.4

De novo

4b Noveld

NND at 29 weeks; no PM

Type 2 collagenopathy

41

5

30

Late onset rhizomelic long bone shortening

? Achondroplasia but targeted FGFR3 analysis negative

FGFR3 c.833A>G p.(Tyr278Cys) (het) NM_000142.4

De novo

4b ClinVar: RCV000017768.27; RCV000415056.1 HGMD: CM066083

LB; rhizomelia all limbs, prominent forehead

Hypochondroplasia

30

6

21

Generalized short long bones

? Skeletal dysplasia

GDF5 c.902G>A p.(Arg301Gln) (het) NM_001319138.1

Maternally inherited VUS

3b Novel

LB

No diagnosis made; early delivery for placental insufficiency

 

7

14

Short long bones with acute angulation of femur, humerus, and radius.

? OI, ?Hypophospatasia

ALPL c.331G>A p.(Ala111Thr) (het) NM_000478.5

AD maternally inherited

4b HGMD: CM980059

LB—X rays and compatible with hypophospatasia, increased urinary phosphoethanolamine

Hypophosphatasia

16

8

20

Mild shortening and bowing of leg bones

? OI

COL1A2 c.2835+1G>A (het) NM_000089.3

AD maternally inherited

5b ClinVar: RCV000490660.1; RCV000490726.1 HGMD: CS042159

LB

Compatible with OI type IV

13

9

20

Mild shortening and bowing of femurs

? OI

IFITM5 c.119C>T p.(Ser40Leu) (het) NM_001025295.2

De novo

5b ClinVar: RCV000351373.1; RCV000162330.3 HGMD: CM144605

ToP; PM compatible with OI

Compatible with OI (published data would classify as type V, but case published not typical of this category)

18

10

24

Short bowed femora. Other long bones ~3rd percentile

? Skeletal dysplasia

COL1A1 c.2362G>A p.(Gly788Ser) (het) NM_000088.3

De novo

5b HGMD: CM070687

LB; X-rays and clinically compatible with moderate–severe OI

Compatible with OI type III/IV

19

11

21

Short, thick bowed femora, evidence of fractures; humerus short, abnormal shape

? Skeletal dysplasia

P3H1 (LEPRE1) c.2041C>T p.(Arg681*) (hom) NM_001243246.1

AR Bi-parental inheritance

5b HGMD: CM086851

Ongoing

Compatible with OI type VIII

12

12

20

Long bones <3rd centile, small chest but ribs not short; no evidence of fractures

Skeletal dysplasia ? 3-M syndrome

OBSL1 c.1273dup p.(Thr425Asnfs*40) (hom)

AR Bi-parental inheritance

5e HGMD: CI093475

Ongoing

3-M syndrome

12

13

22.4

Short long bones, epiphyseal stippling, contractures, irregular ossification of ribs

? Chondrodysplasia punctata

EBP c.451C>T p.(Gln151*) (het) NM_006579.2

De novo

5e HGMD: CM023368

ToP; PM findings compatible with chondrodysplasia punctata

X-linked dominant chondrodysplasia punctata-2

11

14

26

All long bones and chest <5th percentile; bowed femora, talipes

? OI

COL1A1:c.2024_2028+1del (het) NM_000088.3

De novo

5e Novel

Ongoing

Compatible with OI

13

15

23

All long bones <5th centile, abnormal head shape, short ribs

?Skeletal dysplasia

RECQL4 het c.1136G>A p.(Trp379*) NM_004260.3

AR maternal

4e Novel

IUD; awaiting PM

None confirmed; single mutation in recessive gene—suggestive of Baller–Gerold syndrome

17

16

 

Short bowed and curved long bones, narrow chest, FL:AC ratio 0.06

?OI

COL1A1 c.3132_3140del p.(Ala1053_Gly1055del) (het) NM_000088.3

De Novo

5e ClinVar: RCV000413092.1f HGMD: CD013144

ToP subsequent to later ultrasound finding of a diaphragmatic hernia; PM awaited

Compatible with OI

15

  1. AD, autosomal dominant; AR, autosomal recessive; FL:AC, femur length:abdominal circumference; Gest, gestation; HGMD, Human Gene Mutation Database; Het, heterozygote; Hom, homozygote; IUD, intrauterine death; LB, live birth; NND, neonatal death; NT, nuchal translucency; OI, osteogenesis imperfecta; PM, postmortem; SRPS, short-rib polydactyly syndrome; ToP, termination of pregnancy; VUS, variant of uncertain significance.
  2. aDays to diagnosis defined as time from receipt of sample in laboratory or normal array result to identification of variant.
  3. bClassified using the UK best practice guidelines prior to the United Kingdom’s adoption of American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines.14
  4. cThis variants affects a highly conserved amino acid and the majority of in silico analysis tools support the pathogenicity of this variant. The variant was shown to be homozygous in two affected fetuses in this family and heterozygous in both parents. The phenotype in both affected pregnancies was compatible with short-rib thoracic dysplasia 11. This variant has also been detected homozygously in a fetus with a similar phenotype in a poster published online by another laboratory.29
  5. dThis variant affects a glycine residue within the Gly-X-Y repeat motif within the triple helical domain of the COL2A1 gene, which is a common mutational mechanism in collagenopathies.
  6. eClassified using the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics guidelines.6
  7. fSame protein nomenclature—different nucleotide change.