Figure 1: Ferroelectricity by magnon BEC in TlCuCl3.
From: Ferroelectricity by Bose–Einstein condensation in a quantum magnet

(a) Temperature dependence of the dielectric constant observed in AC electric fields E perpendicular to plane. The inset shows the experimental configuration of the measurement. (b) Temperature-field phase diagram. Closed circles shows the peak position of the dielectric constant. Open squares are the critical points, determined by the previous neutron diffraction measurements13. The light blue shedding area turns out to be a multiferroic state with both antiferromagnetic and ferroelectric orders. The magnetic field is normalized by the g-value g=2.06, evaluated by the ESR measurement10. (c) Temperature dependence of the electric polarization P⊥
. (d) Field dependence of the electric polarization P⊥
. A solid curve shows the experimental result. A dashed curve is field dependence of the calculated vector spin chirality <S1 × S2>, multiplied by a constant C=220 (μC m−2). The calculation is carried out in terms of the bond operator theory. Inset shows the field dependence of the vector spin chirality <S1 × S2> and the longitudinal spin component <Sz>, calculated up to 100 T.