Abstract
The manual Tanner-Whitehouse 2 method has recently been transformed into a computer-aided skeletal age scoring system (CASAS), which rates either the complete TW-RUS score (13b model) or a subset consisting of radius, ulna, and the four bones of the third finger (6b model). In this study the reliability of CASAS was evaluated in healthy children, and the 13b model was compared with the manual ratings and with the 6b model in (subgroups of) 151 healthy children, 87 girls with Turner syndrome, and 362 children with constitutionally tall stature. In addition, reference curves for bone maturation in Turner syndrome and constitutionally tall stature are presented. Some of mean differences in methods were statistically significant; however, because these mean differences were less than 0.4 bone age “year,” they are clinically not significant. In all comparisons the range of the difference between the methods (either with the 6b or the 13b model) was considerable, but the combined within- and between-components of variance(0.7%) were in the same order of magnitude as reported for the manual readings. In general, the percentage of equal stage ratings on duplicate assessments was high (±90%). Our data indicate that this computerized method is applicable in these groups of children. The use of the 6b model seems preferable because it is less time-consuming than the rating of 13 bones. In view of the percentages of manual insertions of a stage (up to 8% in all groups) the clinical use of this CASAS version (3.5) seems to be more efficient, particularly with longitudinal studies. Manual substitution of a stage should be avoided, and when performed its percentage and the limits for the acceptance of disagreement should be reported.
Similar content being viewed by others
Log in or create a free account to read this content
Gain free access to this article, as well as selected content from this journal and more on nature.com
or
Abbreviations
- CASAS:
-
computer-aided skeletal age scoring system
- 13b and 6b:
-
13- and 6-bone rating models, respectively, of CASAS
- CA:
-
chronologic age
- BA:
-
bone age
- TW2:
-
Tanner and Whitehouse 2 method of bone age determinations
- MS:
-
maturity score according to Tanner and Whitehouse 2 method
- TS:
-
Turner syndrome
- CTS:
-
constitutionally tall stature
REFERENCES
Tanner JM, Whitehouse RH, Cameron N, Marshall WA, Healy MJR, Goldstein H 1983 Assessment of Skeletal Maturity and Prediction of Adult Height (TW2-Method). Academic Press, London
Taranger J, Bruning B, Claesson I, Karlberg P, Landstrom B 1976 A new method for the assessment of skeletal maturity-the MAT method (mean appearance time of bone stages). Acta Paediatr Scand Suppl 258: 109–120
Beunen G, Cameron N 1980 The reproducibility of TW2 skeletal age assessments by a self-taught assessor. Hum Biol 7: 155–162
Wenzel A, Melsen B 1982 Replicability of assessing radiographs by the Tanner Whitehouse-2 method. Hum Biol 54: 575–581
Tanner JM, Gibbons RD 1994 Automatic bone age measurement using computerized image analysis. J Pediatr Endocrinol 7: 141–145
Tanner JM, Gibbons RG, Bock DR 1992 An image analysis system for TW2 skeletal maturity. Horm Res 37( suppl 4): 11.
Tanner JM, Gibbons RD, Bock RD 1993 advantages of the computer-aided image analysis system for estimating tw skeletal maturity: increased reliability and a continuous scale. Pediatr Res 33( suppl): s35.
Bland JM, Altman DG 1986 Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet 1: 307–310
Eveleth PB, Tanner JM 1990 Worldwide Variation in Human Growth. University Press, Cambridge
Ranke MB, Chavez-Meyer H, Blank B, Frisch H, Häusler G 1991 Spontaneous growth and bone age development in Turner syndrome: results of a multicentric study 1990. In: Ranke MB, Rosenfeld R(eds) Turner Syndrome: Growth Promoting Therapies. Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Amsterdam, pp 101–106
Brook CGD, Murset G, Zachmann M, Prader A 1974 Growth in children with 45,XO Turner's syndrome. Arch Dis Child 49: 789–795
Rochiccioli P, Pienkowski C, Tauber MT 1991 Spontaneous growth in Turner syndrome: a study of 61 cases. In: Ranke MB, Rosenfeld R(eds) Turner Syndrome: Growth Promoting Therapies. Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Amsterdam, 107–112
Greulich WW, Pyle SJ 1959 Radiographic Atlas of Skeletal Development of the Hand and Wrist. Stanford University Press, California
Zachmann M, Ferrandez A, Murset G, Prader A 1975 Estrogen treatment of excessively tall girls. Helv Paediatr Acta 30: 11–30
Zachmann M, Ferrandez A, Murset G, Gnehm HE, Prader A 1976 Testosterone treatment of excessively tall boys. J Pediatr 88: 116–123
John G, Schellong G 1980 Oestrogen therapie hochwuchsiger Madchen. Monatsschr Kinderheilkd 128: 545–550
Stover B, Kollmann F 1983 Ergebnisse der Behandlung hochwuchsiger Madchen mit conjugierten Oestrogenen. Monatsschr Kinderheilkd 130: 36–40
Brämswig JH, Hermeling F, Petrykowski W, Schellong WV 1984 Comparison of height predictions with final adult height in boys with constitutional tall stature. In: Borms J, Hauspie R, Sand A, Susanne C, Hebbelinck M (eds) Human Growth and Development. Plenum, New York, 423–429
Acknowledgements
The authors acknowledge the kind co-operation of Dr. Roland Aarsen for referring the CTS patients. We are indebted to Ares Services S.A. and Discerning Systems for supplying a CASAS system and Dr. Berthon Rikken for the development of additional software applications.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Manuscript dedicated to Professor H.K.A. Visser in honor of his retiremen
Supported by Novo Nordisk Pharma B.V.
Appendix
Appendix
Appendix. The members of the Dutch Working Group on Growth Hormone who participated in this study are:
-
M. Gons and T. Vulsma, Amsterdam
-
H. Delemarre-Van de Waal and G. Hoorweg, Amsterdam
-
J. Waelkens, Eindhoven
-
N. Drayer, Groningen
-
H. Reeser, Den Haag
-
J. M. Wit and W. Oostdijk, Leiden
-
J. Gosen, Leiderdorp
-
W. J. Gerver, Maastricht
-
B. Otten and C. Rongen-Westerlaken, Nijmegen
-
S. de Muinck Keizer-Schrama and S. Drop, Rotterdam
-
M. Jansen, Utrecht
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
van Teunenbroek, A., de Waal, W., Roks, A. et al. Computer-Aided Skeletal Age Scores in Healthy Children, Girls with Turner Syndrome, and in Children with Constitutionally Tall Stature. Pediatr Res 39, 360–367 (1996). https://doi.org/10.1203/00006450-199602000-00028
Received:
Accepted:
Issue date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1203/00006450-199602000-00028
This article is cited by
-
Computer-Assisted Bone Age Assessment: Graphical User Interface for Image Processing and Comparison
Journal of Digital Imaging (2004)
