Table 1 Summary of the analyses of the autoradiographs

From: NanoSIMS and tissue autoradiography reveal symbiont carbon fixation and organic carbon transfer to giant ciliate host

 

Sulfidic pulse

Oxic pulse

 

24-h oxic + oxic pulse

Sulfidic pulse-chase

Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney test

 

AGD

RGD

 

AGD

RGD

 

AGD

RGD

AGD

RGD

sp vs op

sp vs spc

Microzooid symbiont

27.66

107.78 **

 

3.63

112.88 **

 

0.12

21.39

103.36

nd

nd

 

(16.97–28.93)

(107.53–110.50)

 

(3.29–3.67)

(102.94–117.83)

 

(0.12–0.13)

(16.06–27.34)

(101.36–103.83)

  

Stalk symbiont

9.20

51.75

 

2.03

68.30

 

0.02

16.63

80.97

nd

nd

 

(8.17–10.65)

(31.61–69.82)

 

(2.00–3.58)

(61.81–68.76)

 

(0.01–0.08)

(14.22–21.32)

(79.31–90.69)

  

Total symbiont

23.06

100.00

 

2.97

100.00

 

0.09

19.79

100.00

nd

nd

 

(15.79–25.67)

(100–100)

 

(2.91–3.63)

(100–100)

 

(0.08–0.11)

-

(15.96–26.33)

(100–100)

  

Microzooid host

10.44

44.36

 

1.05

32.65

 

0.07

12.65

63.89

nd

*

 

(4.69–11.39)

(35.62–45.25)

 

(0.71–1.18)

(32.53–35.56)

 

(0.06–0.10)

(9.36–21.37)

(63.12–69.60)

  

Stalk host

4.17

19.38

 

0.63

21.61

 

0.03

9.13

50.53

nd

**

 

(0.46–5.60)

(2.89–21.81)

 

(0.43–1.25)

(14.51–24.57)

 

(0.03–0.03)

(8.79–11.56)

(44.40–67.85)

  

Total host

4.56

24.90

 

0.68

20.00

 

0.09

12.92

65.26

nd

***

 

(2.31–6.39)

(9.99–33.75)

 

(0.59–1.10)

(19.04–30.29)

 

(0.04–0.11)

(10.73–18.38)

(61.59–69.8)

  
  1. For each incubation, the medians of the actual grain density (AGD) and relative grain density (RGD) of five replicates are shown together with the interquartile range of the data (Q25–Q75). The RGDs are the grain counts, which are set as a proportion of the overall symbiont grain count. All comparisons were then performed on the RGDs. Within a particular treatment, comparisons of the symbionts covering the microzooid and stalk areas as well as the respective host areas were performed using Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney significance testing. This test was also performed to compare the sulfidic pulse and the oxic pulse (sp vs op), as well as the sulfidic pulse and the sulfidic pulse chase incubations (sp vs spc). Bonferroni correction was then applied
  2. nd not different
  3. *p  < 0.05; **p <  0.01; ***p  < 0.001