Table 1 Study characteristics.
Study (country) | Number of patientsa | Blinding | Analyses | Trial duration (weeks) | Settingb (%) | Diagnosis (%)b | Diagnostic criteriab | Illness duration (yrs) | Mean ageb: yrs (range) | Sexb: Male (%) | Control-Group: Dose (mg/d): mean (range) | Intervention-Group: Dose (mg/d): mean (range) | Jadad score | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Baptista et al.28 (Venezuela) | T: 40 C: 20 I: 20 | DB | OC | 14 | Inpatients (100) | SCZ (NR), SzA (NR) | NR | 30.7c | 47.7 (NR) | 59.5 | OLA: Ø = 10 (FD) | OLA: Ø = 10 (FD) | MET: Ø = NR (850–1700) | 4 |
Baptista et al.27 (Venezuela) | T: 80 C: 40 I: 40 | DB | OC | 12 | In (75)-outpatients (25) | SCZ (95), BD (5) | DSM-IV | NR | 44.1 (>18) | 58.3 | OLA: Ø = 10.3 (5–20) | OLA: Ø = 10.3 (5–20) | MET: Ø = NR (850–2550) | 4 |
Carrizo et al.26 (Venezuela) | T: 61 C: 30 I: 31 | DB | OC | 14 | Outpatients (100) | SCZ (94), SzD (2), BD-I (4) | DSM-IV | 7.3c | 38.9 (>18) | 79.6 | CLZ: Ø = 207.3 (NR) | CLZ: Ø = 180.3 (NR) | MET: Ø = NR (500–1000) | 4 |
Chen et al.25 (China) | T: 55 C: 27 I: 28 | DB | ITT | 24 | In (18)-outpatients (82) | SCZ (NR), SzA (NR) | DSM-IV | 21d | 41.6 (20–65) | 50.9 | CLZ: Ø = 282.4 (NR) | CLZ: Ø = 252.7 (NR) | MET: Ø = NR (1000–1500) | 3 |
Chiu et al.19 (China) | T: 55 C: 18 I: 37 | DB | ITT | 12 | NR | SCZ (NR), SzA (NR) | DSM-IV | 24.8 | 45.6 (20–65) | 43.6 | CLZ: Ø = 261.5 (NR) | 1.CLZ: Ø = 284.8 (NR) | 1.MET: Ø = 500 (NR) | 5 |
2.CLZ: Ø = 263.5 (NR) | 2.MET: Ø = 1000 (NR) | |||||||||||||
Han et al.18 (China) | T: 120 C: 60 I: 60 | DB | ITT | 16 | NR | SCZ (100) | DSM-IV-TR | 4.5 | 43.7 (24–61) | 54.2 | OLA: Ø = NR (NR) | OLA: Ø = NR (NR) | MET: Ø = 1500 (NR) | 3 |
Hebrani et al.21 (Iran) | T: 60 C: 30 I: 30 | DB | OC | 20 | Inpatients (100) | SCZ (100) | DSM-IV-TR | 20.2 | 46.5 (18–75) | 45.9 | CLZ: Ø = 145.6 (NR) | CLZ: Ø = 210.5 (NR) | MET: Ø = NR (500–1000) | 4 |
Jarskog et al.24 (USA) | T: 148 C: 73 I: 75 | DB | ITT | 16 | Outpatients (100) | SCZ (NR), SzA (NR) | DSM-IV | ≥ 1 year | 43.2 (18–65) | 69.2 | APse:: Ø = NR (NR) | APse: Ø = NR(NR) | MET: Ø = NR (1000–2000) | 4 |
Rao et al.20 (China) | T: 145 C: 72 I: 73 | DB | ITT | 8 | Inpatients (100) | SCZ (100) | ICD-10 | 5.5 | 36.2 (16–54) | 53.1 | RIS: Ø = NR (1–6) | RIS: Ø = NR (1–6) | MET: Ø = 1500 (FD) | 3 |
Wu et al.6 2016-Study 1 (China) | T: 162 C: 84 I: 78 | DB | OC | 24 | Outpatients (100) | SCZ (100) | DSM-IV | 0.7 f | 26.1 (18–40) | 50.0 | APse: Ø = NR (NR) | APse: Ø = NR (NR) | MET: Ø = NR (500–1000) | 2 |
Wu et al.6 2016-Study 2 (China) | T: 39 C: 14 I: 25 | DB | OC | 24 | Outpatients (100) | SCZ (100) | DSM-IV | 0.8 f | 25.5 (18–40) | 0 | APse: Ø = NR (NR) | APse: Ø = NR (NR) | MET: Ø = NR (500–1000) | 5 |
Zhang23 (China) | T: 80 C: 40 I: 40 | DB | ITT | 10 | Inpatients (100) | SCZ (100) | CCMD-3 | 1.7 | 29.8 (17–47) | 51.3 | OLA: Ø = NR (10–20) | OLA: Ø = NR (10–20) | MET: Ø = 1000 (FD) | 4 |
Zhou et al.22 (China) | T: 170 C: 84 I: 86 | DB | ITT | 20 | Inpatients (100) | SCZ (100) | ICD-10 | 0.5 | 28.0 (18–46) | 55.3 | RIS: Ø = NR (4–5) | RIS: Ø = NR (4–5) | MET: Ø = 750 (NR) | 2 |