Table 4 Comparison of the advantages and limitations of different stimulatory agents for CAR-T cell preparations.

From: Harmonisation of quality control tests for academic production of CAR-T cells: a position paper from the WP-bioproduction of the UNITC consortium

Stimulatory Agent

Signal

Advantages

Limitations

Remarks

Recombinant Protein

Restricted antigen

Simple, quantification of antigen number possible

Low stability (3 months) and cost (€350 for 50 µg, approx. €50/test)

Use of an irrelevant protein as a control

Coated Beads

Restricted antigen

Simple, quantification of antigen number possible

Low stability (3 months after reconstitution and storage at −80 °C) and cost (€1 300 for 2 mg, approx. €7–8 per well, €70–80/test)

Use of irrelevant beads as a control

Allogeneic Human Cell Line

Antigen-dependent and independent

Immunological synapse, mimics target in indication

Alloreactivity

Need to subtract alloreactivity with antigen-negative cell line

Murine Cells

Antigen-dependent and independent

Immunological synapse

Potential xenogeneic reactivity (not detected under test conditions)

Use of antigen-negative cell line as control