Table 2 Summary of methods for intervention and control
Authors | Year | HBPM method: type/method (device) | Outcome BP | Co-intervention 1 | Co-intervention 2 | Co-intervention 3 | Control |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vetter et al. [11] | 2000 | Wrist/oscillometric (Omron HEM-605) | OBP | None | – | – | Usual care |
Mehos et al. [12] | 2000 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-702) | OBP | Education/change in medication | Telephone calls including checking BP on a phone | Pharmacist support | Usual care |
Rogers et al. [13] | 2001 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Welch Allyn 52500) | 24 h-ABP | None | Telemonitoring (telecommunication) | – | Usual care |
Broege et al. [14] | 2001 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-702) | OBP, day/night ABP | Setting target BP | Telephone calls including checking BP on a phone | – | Setting target BP |
Rudd et al. [15] | 2004 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-751) | OBP | Change in medication | Telephone calls including checking BP on a phone | Nurse support | Usual care |
Halme et al. [16] | 2005 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M4) | OBP/HBP | Setting target BP | – | – | Setting target BP |
Zillich et al. [17] | 2005 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-737A) | OBP | Change in medication | – | Pharmacist support | Usual care |
Marquez-Contreras et al. [18] | 2006 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M4) | OBP | None | – | – | Usual care |
Verberk et al. [19] | 2007 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-705-CP) | OBP, 24 h-/day/night ABP, HBP | Change in medication | – | – | Usual care |
Kauric-Klein and Artinian [20] | 2007 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron 1C) | OBP | Other (hemodialysis) | – | – | Education |
Artinian et al. [21] | 2007 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-767) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | Nurse support | Usual care |
Tobe et al. [22] | 2008 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-767P) | OBP | Change in medication | – | – | Usual care |
Madsen et al. [23] | 2008 | Upper arm/semi-automatic oscillometric (Omron 705IT) | Day/night ABP | None | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Green et al. [24] | 2008 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-705-CP) | OBP | Education | (1) Web-site use (2) Web-site use | (1) None (2) Pharmacist support | Usual care |
Parati et al. [25] | 2009 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Tensioday, Tensiomed) | OBP, day ABP | None | Telemonitoring | – | Setting target BP |
da Silva et al. [26] | 2009 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-705-CP) | 24 h-ABP/HBP | Change in medication | – | – | Usual care |
Dejesus et al. [27] | 2009 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Life Source UA-767 Plus) | OBP | Education | – | (A class focusing on hypertension in diabetes) | Education (data based on no intervention group was not considered) |
Bosworth et al. [28] | 2009 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM 773AC) or wrist/oscillometric (Omron HEM 637) | OBP | None | Mailing BP logs to the center | – | Usual care |
Rinfret et al. [29] | 2009 | Upper arm/digital (Omron HEM-711AC) | 24 h-ABP | Education/change in medication | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Godwin et al. [30] | 2010 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-767) | 24 h-ABP | None | – | – | Usual care |
McManus et al. [31] | 2010 | Upper arm/automated sphygmomanometer (Omron 705IT) | OBP | Change in medication | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Varis and Kantola [32] | 2010 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron 1C) | OBP | None | Mailing BP logs to the center | – | Usual care |
Bosworth et al. [33] | 2011 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-767PC) | OBP | Change in medication | Telemedicine (Behavioral Management Intervention group was not considered) | Nurse support | Usual care |
Magid et al. [34] | 2011 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-767) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | Pharmacist support | Usual care |
Hebert et al. [35] | 2012 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-712C) | OBP | (1) None (2) Education | (1) None (2) Telephone calls including checking BP on a phone | (1) None (2) Nurse support | Usual care |
Fuchs et al. [36] | 2012 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-705-CP) | OBP, 24 h-/day/night ABP | Half of them received pharmacist care | – | – | Usual care (but half of them received pharmacist care) |
Piette et al. [37] | 2012 | Unknown device (in-home cuffs for measurement of BP [on Web page of protocol]) | OBP | Education | Automated telephone call | – | Usual care |
Williams et al. [38] | 2012 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-787) | OBP | Education | – | Nurse support | Usual care |
Kerry et al. [39] | 2013 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M6) | OBP | Education | Telephone calls including checking BP on a phone | Nurse support | Usual care |
Magid et al. [40] | 2013 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-790IT) | OBP | Education/change in medication | Telemonitoring | Pharmacist support | Usual care |
McKinstry et al. [41] | 2013 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Stabil-O-Graph mobil) | Day ABP | None | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Margolis et al. [42] | 2013 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D 767PC) | OBP | Education/change in medication | Telemonitoring | Pharmacist support | Education |
Ogedegbe et al. [43] | 2014 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Microlife BP 3AC1-1) | OBP | Education | – | – | Education |
Stewart et al. [44] | 2014 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron T9IT) | OBP | Education Change in medication | – | Pharmacist support | Usual care |
McManus et al. [45] | 2014 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Microlife Watch BP Home) | OBP | Change in medication | – | – | Usual care |
Hosseininasab et al. [46] | 2014 | Wrist/oscillometric (Samsung C&T SHB-200w) | OBP | None | – | – | Usual care |
Kim et al. [47] | 2014 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D UA-767) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | Nurses and nutritionists support | Usual care |
Yi et al. [48] | 2015 | Unknown device but considered to be cuff-type | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | — | Usual care |
Hanley et al. [49] | 2015 | Upper arm/oscillometric (IEM Stabil-O-graph) | Day ABP | None | Telemonitoring | Nurse support | Usual care |
Aekplakorn et al. [50] | 2016 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-7117) | OBP | None | – | – | Usual care |
Kim et al. [51] | 2016 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Withings BP Monitor) | OBP | Education | Reminder by an App | – | Usual care |
Tzourio et al. [52] | 2017 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M6) | OBP, HBP | None | – | – | Usual care |
Klarskov et al. [53] | 2018 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Microlife BP 3AC1) | OBP, day/night ABP | None | – | – | Usual care |
Martinez et al. [54] | 2018 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Microlife WatchHome) | 24 h-/day/night ABP | None | – | – | Usual care |
McManus et al. [55] | 2018 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M10-IT) | OBP | Change in medication | (1) None (2) Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Pan et al. [56] | 2018 | Upper arm/oscillometric (“maibobo” RBP3900 and RBP9000) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | A technology including an App | Usual care |
Skolarus et al. [57] | 2018 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron BP760) | OBP | Education | SMS message to remind BP measurements | – | Usual care |
Cuffee et al. [58] | 2019 | [Upper arm/oscillometric (Carrera Upper Arm BP Monitor)] | 24 h-ABP | None | – | – | Usual care Education |
Gu et al. [59] | 2020 | Upper arm/oscillometric (KD598, Andon) | OBP | Other (Pedometer group was not considered) | Telephone calls | – | Education |
Ojji et al. [60] | 2020 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M3 HEM-7131-E) | OBP | None | – | – | Usual care |
Zha et al. [61] | 2020 | Wrist/oscillometric (iHealth BP7 Wireless BP Monitor, iHealth Lab Inc.) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | Nurse support | Usual care |
Ionov et al. [62] | 2021 | Unknown but the device had to be listed in the “STRIDE BP” database. | OBP, 24 h-ABP | Change in medication | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
McManus et al. [63] | 2021 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M3 monitor) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | A technology including an App | Usual care |
Zhang et al. [64] | 2021 | Upper arm/oscillometric (HEM-7051, Omron Healthcare) | OBP | Setting target BP | – | – | Usual care (setting target BP) |
Akl et al. [65] | 2021 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron MIT Elite Plus arm monitor) | OBP | Education | – | – | Usual care |
Margolis et al. [66] | 2022 | Upper arm/oscillometric (A&D Medical 767PC) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | Pharmacist support | Usual care |
Okoro et al. [67] | 2022 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Chidalex, Joytech Healthcare Co. Ltd) | OBP | Education | Telephone calls including checking BP on a phone | Pharmacist support | Usual care |
Muijsers et al. [68] | 2022 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Withings BP Monitor) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Calderón-Anyosa et al. [69] | 2023 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron Series 10) | OBP | Change in medication | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Doogue et al. [70] | 2023 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M10-IT) | OBP | Change in medication | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
Hoppe et al. [71] | 2023 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron, 7 Series) | OBP, 24 h-ABP | Education | Telephone calls including checking BP on a phone | Health coaching | Usual care |
Leupold et al. [72] | 2023 | Upper arm/oscillometric (BOSO® Medicus Family 4) | OBP | Change in medication | Telemonitoring | A technology including an App | Usual care |
Martínez-Ibáñez et al. [73] | 2023 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron M3 HEM-7131-E) | OBP | Change in medication | – | – | Usual care |
Nejamis et al. [74] | 2023 | Upper arm/oscillometric (automatic home BP monitor, model unspecified) | OBP | None (peer mentoring arm was excluded) | – | – | Usual care |
Ramos-Zavala et al. [75] | 2023 | Upper arm/oscillometric (Omron HEM-9200T) | OBP | Education | Telemonitoring | – | Usual care |
