Fig. 3
From: Nuclear spin assisted quantum tunnelling of magnetic monopoles in spin ice

Spontaneous evolution of the monopole density during a wait time in zero applied field. This is gauged by the growth of magnetisation (M) and monopole current density (Jm = dM/dt) after a field is applied; comparison of the different isotopic samples reveals the effect of nuclear spins on the monopole mobility. a 162Dy2Ti2O7 (162Dy) and b 163Dy2Ti2O7 (163Dy), both measured at T = 80 mK, and c Ho2Ti2O7 (HTO, T = 200 mK). nat Dy2Ti2O7 (DTO) can be seen in Supplementary Fig. 4. The samples were first prepared using the AQP protocol outlined in (d) and discussed further in Methods. After the specified wait periods, a field of 0.08 T was applied and the magnetisation as a function of time was recorded. All measurements shown in the figure were made with the field along the [111] axis; examples for other directions are given in the Supplementary Figs. 10 and 11. e Plot of the value of the magnetisation M obtained after the first 400 s for the three samples shown to the left, and for natDy2Ti2O7 vs. log wait time. Note that the magnetisation values at 400 s remain far from the expected equilibrium value. f The monopole current Jm = dM/dt at t = 0 for the three samples shown to the left vs. log wait time. Also shown is the monopole current for natDy2Ti2O7, and the monopole current for Ho2Ti2O7 measured at 80 mK