Fig. 4
From: Nuclear spin assisted quantum tunnelling of magnetic monopoles in spin ice

Wait time and isotope dependences of magnetothermal avalanches. This gives further evidence of the effect of nuclear spins on the monopole mobility. Avalanches of the magnetisation were recorded while the field was ramped at 20 mT s−1 for a 162 Dy2Ti2O7 (162Dy) and b 163 Dy2Ti2O7 (163Dy), both measured at T = 80 mK, and c Ho2Ti2O7 (HTO, measured at T = 200 mK). Magnetothermal avalanches for natDy2Ti2O7 (DTO) can be seen in Supplementary Fig. 4. The samples were first prepared using the AQP and then followed by various wait times (as outlined in (d) and discussed in methods) except for the curves marked CC, where the sample was first prepared using the conventional zero field cooled protocol (red squares). Also shown for each of the samples is the equilibrium M vs. μ0H taken at 900 mK (solid black dots). All measurements shown in the figure were made with the field along the [111] axis; examples for other directions are given in the Supplementary Figs. 9–11. e Plot of difference in avalanche field ΔHava = Hava(tw) − Hava (tw = minimum) against log wait time for the data shown in the left as well as natDy2Ti2O7 (DTO, see Supplementary Fig. 4)