Table 1 Community Temperature Index temporal change (CTIr) by factors and its levels

From: Cross-basin and cross-taxa patterns of marine community tropicalization and deborealization in warming European seas

Factor

Level

n

CTIr mean (°C y−1)

CTIr SE

DF

t-value

p-value

AICc

Biological group

CHB benthos

7

0.01171

0.00991

1659

1181

0.2378

1841.87

CSB benthos

19

0.02553

0.00188

1659

13,546

<0.0001

Zooplankton

4

0.01641

0.00629

1659

2605

0.0093

Demersal crustaceans

7

0.00464

0.00590

1659

0786

0.4315

Cephalopods

10

−0.00792

0.00536

1659

−1476

0.1400

Fish

18

0.03234

0.00299

1659

10,831

<0.0001

Habitat

Benthic / demersal

52

0.02061

0.00149

1661

13,820

<0.0001

1843.39

Estuarine

3

0.07732

0.00624

1661

12,387

<0.0001

Pelagic

10

0.01822

0.00487

1661

3741

0.0002

Region

Baltic Sea

4

0.02037

0.00526

1662

3872

0.0001

1744.97

Mediterranean Sea

30

0.00512

0.00306

1662

1674

0.0943

Northeast Atlantic

31

0.02854

0.00171

1662

16,668

<0.0001

Basin type

Non-enclosed

28

0.02482

0.00189

1663

13,069

<0.0001

1850.98

Semi-enclosed seas

37

0.01876

0.00261

1663

7178

<0.0001

  1. Test for significant differences in mean CTIr from zero, according to linear mixed models. t- and p-values correspond to two-sided Wald test. Significant p-values (p < 0.05) are in bold.
  2. HB hard bottom, SB soft bottom, SE standard error, AICc Akaike’s Information Criterion corrected, DF degrees of freedom.