Table 1 Assembly statistics for different assemblers using the barcode-removed short-reads or linked-reads on mock communities
From: Exploring high-quality microbial genomes by assembling short-reads with long-range connectivity
 | Pangaea | Athena | Supernova | cloudSPAdes | MEGAHIT | metaSPAdes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ATCC-MSA-1003 (stLFR) | ||||||
Total assembly length | 59,484,233 | 52,159,846 | 35,226,545 | - | 55,506,708 | 57,225,487 |
Genome fraction (%) | 84.43 | 77.12 | 52.21 | - | 81.99 | 83.99 |
Longest alignment | 2,853,278 | 2,281,647 | 1,105,108 | - | 883,580 | 883,552 |
Overall N50 | 1,619,916 | 875,747 | 243,194 | - | 127,879 | 132,556 |
Overall N70 | 614,609 | 615,896 | 132,825 | - | 63,957 | 63,879 |
Overall N90 | 5,248 | 110,802 | 50,969 | - | 5,222 | 3,688 |
Overall NA50 | 731,990 | 677,911 | 215,052 | - | 116,995 | 125,586 |
NA50 per strain | 628,059 | 576,621 | 145,646 | - | 140,463 | 134,477 |
NGA50 per strain | 677,353 | 575,371 | 137,023 | - | 133,877 | 133,978 |
ATCC-MSA-1003 (TELL-Seq) | ||||||
Total assembly length | 61,990,266 | 60,847,375 | 56,748,937 | 62,316,993 | 60,291,592 | 60,648,311 |
Genome fraction (%) | 82.63 | 81.99 | 76.46 | 82.44 | 82.10 | 82.46 |
Longest alignment | 4,968,123 | 4,968,084 | 1,096,372 | 884,364 | 867,473 | 776,102 |
Overall N50 | 1,360,322 | 466,498 | 102,757 | 127,419 | 128,069 | 112,342 |
Overall N70 | 465,633 | 184,646 | 41,121 | 56,614 | 54,222 | 49,466 |
Overall N90 | 8,045 | 9,929 | 8,084 | 6,051 | 5,893 | 5,429 |
Overall NA50 | 649,672 | 361,569 | 97,312 | 118,159 | 112,513 | 105,630 |
NA50 per strain | 838,457 | 483,734 | 123,277 | 129,001 | 122,932 | 119,253 |
NGA50 per strain | 887,107 | 485,196 | 121,657 | 129,531 | 121,938 | 118,391 |
ATCC-MSA-1003 (10x) | ||||||
Total assembly length | 58,860,253 | 52,292,807 | 89,828,047 | - | 56,558,134 | - |
Genome fraction (%) | 83.23 | 77.19 | 75.08 | - | 82.74 | - |
Largest alignment | 2,277,835 | 2,278,264 | 974,529 | - | 883,602 | - |
Overall N50 | 1,033,793 | 601,544 | 32,128 | - | 151,002 | - |
Overall N70 | 564,696 | 356,490 | 12,725 | - | 73,366 | - |
Overall N90 | 13,052 | 73,456 | 4,075 | - | 6,715 | - |
Overall NA50 | 483,416 | 453,155 | 30,194 | - | 132,728 | - |
NA50 per strain | 421,157 | 328,424 | 93,097 | - | 141,574 | - |
NGA50 per strain | 441,029 | 334,491 | 89,993 | - | 143,179 | - |
CAMI-high | ||||||
Total assembly length | 799,834,811 | 773,344,531 | 757,315,614 | 752,648,273 | 772,095,404 | 759,108,499 |
Genome fraction (%) | 27.71 | 27.33 | 26.69 | 26.66 | 27.46 | 27.01 |
Longest alignment | 3,402,679 | 3,402,661 | 2,700,464 | 2,525,441 | 2,378,494 | 2,518,442 |
Overall N50 | 254,141 | 211,169 | 135,915 | 117,495 | 114,277 | 133,877 |
Overall N70 | 124,320 | 108,630 | 61,513 | 54,187 | 52,909 | 62,467 |
Overall N90 | 38,713 | 38,425 | 15,770 | 10,227 | 10,946 | 12,521 |
Overall NA50 | 212,494 | 201,566 | 132,676 | 113,425 | 110,658 | 132,603 |
NA50 per strain | 66,310 | 66,060 | 46,464 | 40,507 | 39,340 | 45,216 |
NGA50 per strain | 54,412 | 49,896 | 34,201 | 31,266 | 28,301 | 34,547 |
Non-zero NGA50 | 195 | 180 | 175 | 177 | 180 | 177 |
ZYMO | ||||||
Total assembly length | 36,094,665 | 35,254,802 | 25,103,660 | 35,843,842 | 35,358,538 | 35,511,020 |
Genome fraction (%) | 49.24 | 48.14 | 34.27 | 47.99 | 48.38 | 48.46 |
Longest alignment | 2,839,942 | 2,717,703 | 768,486 | 1,012,282 | 1,079,942 | 847,644 |
Overall N50 | 1,094,665 | 761,749 | 288,912 | 210,427 | 124,248 | 191,688 |
Overall N70 | 638,009 | 445,656 | 139,701 | 136,651 | 70,860 | 106,796 |
Overall N90 | 180,146 | 157,620 | 45,025 | 60,073 | 25,980 | 44,425 |
Overall NA50 | 1,072,622 | 760,284 | 226,947 | 208,894 | 116,738 | 191,688 |
NA50 per strain | 1,066,276 | 927,278 | 136,210 | 245,562 | 179,245 | 183,935 |
NGA50 per strain | 1,083,616 | 938,270 | 132,015 | 246,262 | 177,318 | 179,371 |