Table 1 Selected system parameters for various GW sources for the detection of single gravitons through stimulated absorption

From: Detecting single gravitons with quantum sensing

GW source

GW170817 (NS–NS merger)

GW170817 (NS–NS merger)

GW170608 (BH–BH merger)

GW150914 (BH–BH merger)

J1301+0833 (black-widow pulsar)

J1748-2446ad (fast-spinning pulsar)

A0620-00 (BH Superradiance)

Primordial (rare BH–BH merger)

\({f}=\frac{\omega }{2\pi }\)

100 Hz

150 Hz

175 Hz

200 Hz

1085 Hz

1433 Hz

33 kHz

5.5 MHz

h0(f)

2 × 10−22

2 × 10−22

2 × 10−22

10−21

<10−25

<10−25

3 × 10−21

10−16

Mc

1.19M

1.19M

7.9M

28.6M

Continuous

Continuous

Continuous

5 × 10−4M

Material

Beryllium

Aluminum

Niobium

CuAl6%

Niobium

Superfluid He-4

Sapphire

Quartz

νo

13 km/s

5.4 km/s

5 km/s

4.1 km/s

5 km/s

238 m/s

10 km/s

6.3 km/s

T

1 mK

1 mK

1 mK

1 mK

0.1 μK

0.1 μK

0.6 K

0.6 mK

Q-factor

1010

1010

1010

1010

1010

1013

1010

1010

M

~15 kg

~250 kg

~9 t

~6 t

>52 t

>20 t

~100 kg

~10 g

  1. Here, f is the resonant frequency, h0(f) the GW amplitude at that frequency, Mc the chirp mass of the GW source in terms of solar mass M where applicable, v0 the speed of sound, T the environmental temperature, Q the mechanical Q-factor of the mode and M the mass of the required resonator. Experiments in the LIGO band would focus on transient GWs (first four columns) and could correlate events to LIGO detections of black hole (BH) or neutron star (NS) mergers. Nearby NS mergers32 with low chirp mass Mc provide the best candidates, shown in the first two columns. For higher frequencies, the sources are of a speculative nature, such as continuous GWs from pulsars at kHz frequencies34,36, and speculative sources due to new physics in the ultra-high frequency range37. The last column corresponds to a possible rare event of such a hypothetical source40. For continuous sources, the temperature is calculated which ensures the graviton absorption rate given in Eq. (5) is larger than the rate of thermal phonons for the given Q-factor and frequency. For transient sources, the temperature is calculated such that the thermal-phonon rate integrated over a 40 s observation-window yields an excitation probability lower than P ≈ 0.3.