Table 1 The table shows the detailed characteristics of the employed Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) scenarios featuring Afforestation/Reforestation (AR) and Ocean Alkalinity Enhancement (OAE) and how linear expectations are formulated

From: No compromise in efficiency from the co-application of a marine and a terrestrial CDR method

Scenario

AR by 2099 (Mha)

Alkalinity by 2099 (Pmol)

Assess linearity compared to:

Removal Efficiency (%)

\(\frac{{{{{\boldsymbol{C}}}}}_{{{{\boldsymbol{land}}}}}{{{\boldsymbol{uptake}}}}\,\left({{{{\boldsymbol{GtCO}}}}}_{{{{\boldsymbol{2}}}}}\right)}{{{{\boldsymbol{100}}}}\, {{{\boldsymbol{Mha}}}}}\)

\(\frac{{{{{\boldsymbol{C}}}}}_{{{{\boldsymbol{ocean}}}}}{{{\boldsymbol{uptake}}}}\,\left({{{{\boldsymbol{GtCO}}}}}_{{{{\boldsymbol{2}}}}}\right)}{{{{\boldsymbol{Pmol}}}}}\)

REF

halfAR

463.5

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{atmo}}^{{halfAR}-{REF}}}{{\varDelta C}_{{land}}^{{halfAR}-{REF}}}\)

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{land}}^{{halfAR}-{REF}}}{{Mha}/100}\)

AR

927

2 * halfAR

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{atmo}}^{{AR}-{REF}}}{{\varDelta C}_{{land}}^{{AR}-{REF}}}\)

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{land}}^{{AR}-{REF}}}{{Mha}/100}\)

halfOAE

8

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{atmo}}^{{halfOAE}-{REF}}}{{\varDelta C}_{{ocean}}^{{halfOAE}-{REF}}}\)

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{ocean}}^{{halfOAE}-{REF}}}{{Pmol}}\)

OAE

16

2 * halfOAE

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{atmo}}^{{OAE}-{REF}}}{{\varDelta C}_{{ocean}}^{{OAE}-{REF}}}\)

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{ocean}}^{{OAE}-{REF}}}{{Pmol}}\)

halfMixed

463.5

8

halfAR + halfOAE

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{land}}^{{halfMixed}-{REF}}}{{Mha}/100}\)

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{ocean}}^{{halfMixed}-{REF}}}{{Pmol}}\)

Mixed

927

16

(1) 2 * halfMixed

(2) AR + OAE

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{land}}^{{Mixed}-{REF}}}{{Mha}/100}\)

\(\frac{{\varDelta C}_{{ocean}}^{{Mixed}-{REF}}}{{Pmol}}\)

  1. The table also shows how the removal efficiency and carbon uptake per unit of CDR application are expressed as a function of changes in atmospheric (Catmo), land (Cland), and ocean (Cocean) carbon. For every scenario, 3 ensemble members for each Earth System Model (ESM) are available, spanning from 2015 to 2099.