Table 1 Task Ratings from Delphi Rounds 1 and 2.

From: Harmonizing cross-cultural and transdiagnostic assessment of social cognition by expert panel consensus

 

Number of Times Nominated for Each Use

     

Task name

Cross-Cultural

Trans-diagnostic

Further Development

Round 1 Quality Rating

Round 1 IQR

Round 2 Quality Rating

Round 2 IQR

Included in Round 3

Affective Responsiveness Task53

  

1

2.05

.50

  

X

Ambiguous Intentions Hostility Questionnaire (AIHQ)54

5

6

1

2.47

1.00

  

X

Bell-Lysaker Emotion Recognition Task (BLERT)17

6

3

1

2.86

2.00

2.44

1.00

X

Benton Face Recognition Test (BFRT)55

 

1

 

1.90

2.00

1.35

1.00

 

Brune’s Picture Sequencing Test56

1

1

 

1.89

1.00

   

Combined Stories task (COST)57

1

 

1

2.44

1.00

  

X

Continuous Facial Sequence Task (CFST)58

 

1

 

2.07

.50

  

X

Davos Assessment of Cognitive Biases Scale (DACOBS)59

  

1

1.89

1.00

   

Dynamic Interactive Social Cognition Training in Virtual Reality (DiSCoVR)60

  

1

1.47

1.00

   

Dynamic Virtual Faces(DVFs)61

1

  

2.16

.00

  

X

Emotion in Biological Motion12

5

2

1

2.24

1.00

  

X

Ekman Faces Test (FEEST)62

2

3

 

2.67

1.00

  

X

Emotion Recognition Index (ERI)63

1

5

 

1.85

1.50

1.40

1.00

 

Emotion Recognition Task (ERT) - CANTAB version64,65

3

4

1

2.43

1.00

  

X

Emotional Perspective Taking Task(EPTT)53

2

2

2

2.61

1.00

  

X

Emotional Stroop, e.g.,66

 

1

 

1.25

.50

   

Empathic Accuracy Task67

 

1

1

2.26

1.00

  

X

Empathy Test68

 

1

 

2.33

1.00

  

X

Face Emotion Discrimination Test (FEDT)69

 

1

 

2.28

.00

  

X

Facial Emotion Identification Task (FEIT)69

 

1

 

2.16

.75

  

X

False Belief Theory of Mind Stories70

 

1

 

2.19

.50

  

X

Faux Pas Test71

2

2

1

2.43

1.00

  

X

Florida Affect Battery (FAB)72

 

1

 

2.22

1.00

  

X

Geneva Emotion Recognition Test (GERT)

2

3

2

2.39

1.00

  

X

Half Profile of Nonverbal Sensitivity (Half-PONS)73

  

1

1.63

1.00

   

Happé’s Cartoon Task74

 

3

 

2.05

2.00

1.82

1.00

X

Heider and Simmel Triangle Task75

1

  

1.71

1.25

1.28

.25

 

High-Risk Social Challenge (HiSoC)76

  

1

1.83

2.00

1.39

1.00

 

Hinting Task15,77

7

9

2

2.65

1.00

  

X

Intentionality Bias Task (IBT)78

  

2

2.13

1.50

1.63

1.00

X

Internal, Personal and Situational Attributions Questionnaire (IPSAQ)79

2

2

 

2.22

1.25

1.75

1.00

X

Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI)80

1

1

 

2.14

1.50

1.94

1.25

X

Levels of Emotional Awareness Scale (LEAS)81

1

1

 

2.12

1.00

  

X

Lecture Intentionnelle en Situation – Versailles (LIS-V)82

1

1

 

2.33

n/a

   

Mayer-Salovey-Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test (MSCEIT)83

6

2

1

2.32

1.00

  

X

Metacognition Assessment Scale-Abbreviated (MAS-A)84

  

1

2.00

1.75

1.35

.50

X

Metaphor and irony stories85

 

1

 

1.79

1.00

   

MINI Social Cognition & Emotional Assessment (MINI-SEA)86

 

1

1

2.26

1.00

  

X

Mini-Profile Of Nonverbal Sensitivity (Mini-PONS)87

1

1

 

2.35

1.00

  

X

Modified Reversal Dictator Game88

1

1

 

1.38

1.00

   

Movie for the Assessment of Social Cognition (MASC)89

1

2

2

2.58

1.00

  

X

Multi-faceted Empathy Test (MET)90

 

2

 

2.26

1.00

  

X

Multilingual Communicative Interaction Database91

 

1

 

1.78

1.00

   

Multimodal Emotion Recognition Test (MERT)92

1

1

 

2.22

.25

  

X

NIH Toolbox Adult Social Relationship Scales93

 

1

 

1.39

2.00

1.06

.00

 

Observable Social Cognition Task (OSCARS)94

1

1

 

2.11

1.25

1.88

.50

X

Penn Emotion Differentiation Test (PEDT)95

  

1

1.83

1.25

1.88

1.00

 

Penn Emotion Recognition Test (ER-40)16

5

7

1

2.90

.75

  

X

Perceptual animacy96

1

1

 

1.38

1.00

   

Reading the Mind in the Eyes Test (RMET)97

7

9

1

2.15

2.00

1.50

.00

X

Reading the Mind in the Voice (RMVT)98

 

1

 

2.28

1.00

  

X

Self Referential Memory, Ownership99

 

1

 

1.24

0.0

   

Self Referential Memory, Self-reference Effect (SRE)100

1

  

1.31

.75

   

Short Story Task (SST)101

  

1

1.53

1.00

   

Social and Occupational Functioning Assessment Scale (SOFAS)102

 

1

 

1.12

0.0

   

Social Attribution Task – Multiple Choice (SAT-MC)103

1

2

1

2.25

1.00

  

X

Social Communication Disorders Checklist104

1

  

1.59

1.00

   

Social Cue Recognition Test (SCRT)105

2

2

 

1.94

.5

   

Social Functioning Questionnaire (SFQ)106

 

1

 

1.18

0.0

   

Social Functioning Scale (SFS)107

2

1

 

1.18

0.0

   

Social Instrumental Learning108

1

  

1.45

1.00

   

Social Judgment Task109

 

1

 

1.81

0.75

   

Social Learning Task110,111

  

1

1.46

1.00

   

Social Norms Questionnaire112

 

1

 

2.00

0.0

  

X

Social Perception and Interaction Database (SoPID)113

  

1

2.07

1.25

1.87

1.00

X

Social Skills Performance Assessment (SSPA)114

  

2

1.83

2.00

1.24

1.00

 

Strange Stories Short Film Task (SSFT)115

1

  

2.27

1.00

  

X

Strange Stories Task116

2

4

 

2.33

1.00

  

X

Test de Reconnaissance des Emotions Faciales (TREF)117

1

2

 

2.11

1.00

  

X

The Awareness of Social Inference Test (TASIT)118

4

6

1

2.80

0.75

  

X

The Interview Task119

  

1

1.71

1.00

   

The Penn Emotion Acuity Test (PEAT)120

 

1

1

2.07

.25

  

X

The Personality Pairs Task (PPT)119

  

1

1.25

.75

   

The Self-other Differentiation Paradigm using Perceptual Matching121

1

1

 

1.27

1.00

   

The Social Attribution Task121

 

1

 

2.24

2.00

1.94

.50

X

The Social Knowledge Test (SKT)121

 

1

 

2.5

1.00

  

X

Theory of Mind by Humor Comprehension and Appreciation Test ToM-HCAT)122

2

  

1.80

1.00

   

Theory of Mind-15 (TOM-15)123

 

1

 

1.77

1.00

   

Triangles Task/Frith-Happé Animations Test124

1

1

2

2.11

2.00

2.00

2.00

X

Virtual Assessment of Mentalising Ability (VAMA)125

  

1

2.65

1.00

  

X

Whodunit126

1

  

1.60

1.00

   

Tasks Introduced at Round 2 by RHG Members

 

Animated Shape Videos127

     

1.75

1.75

 

Brief Assessment of Social Skills (BASS)128

     

1.73

1.0

 

Cartoon Intentions Task129

     

1.92

1.75

 

Contextual Assessment of Social Skills (CASS)130

     

1.40

1.0

 

Edinburgh Social Cognition Test (ESCoT)131

     

2.44

1.00

X

Emotion Recognition Test64,132

     

2.38

1.00

X

Empathy Quotient (EQ)133

     

1.93

1.0

 

Interpersonal Perception Task (IPT)134

     

1.57

1.0

 

La Trobe Communication Questionnaire135

     

1.40

1.0

 

Questionnaire of Cognitive and Affective Empathy (QCAE)136

     

2.20

1.0

X

  1. Quality ratings were made using a 5-point scale, ranging from 0–4: 0 = not possible to rate or insufficient information, 1 = inadequate, 2 = adequate, 3 = good, 4 = excellent. Designations of “n/a” indicate tasks for which IQR could not be calculated due to a lack of non-zero scores.