Table 1 Summary of studies of inactivation of E. coli and MS2 virus with different technologies

From: Virus and bacteria inactivation by CO2 bubbles in solution

Pathogen

Treatment

Log 10 reduction

Time (s)

Solution

pH

Solution temp, °C

Source

E. coli

Thermal inactivation 60 °C

6 log

1800

Sewage water

8

60

38

2.0 mg O3/l

1.3 log

300

Tap water

7.6

23

39

2.0 mg Cl2/l

2 log

300

Tap water

7.6

23

39

UV (0.78 mW/cm2) at 295–400 nm

3.8 log

300

Natural water

7

Room temp.

40

DPCD, CO2 at 197 atm and 34 °C

2.5 log

600

Sterilised water

 

34

41

Bubble column, CO2 at 200 °C, 1 atm

2.3 log

300

0.17M NaCl

6

49

Fig. 2b, this study

MS2 virus

0.1 mg O3/l

1.2

180

Ultrapure water

7

22

42

1.0 mg H2O2/l

0.001 log

90

0.01 M Phosphate buffer

6-10

3–10

43

30 mg Cl2/l

1 log

300

Primary sewage effluent

8

15

44

UV (0.19 mW/cm2)

3.5 log

180

Ultrapure water

7

22

42

Bubble column, CO2 at 200 °C, 1 atm

3 log

230

0.17 M NaCl

6

49

Fig. 1, this study

Bubble column, air at 200 °C, 1 atm

0.17 log

300

0.17 M NaCl

6

52

8