Table 5 Published chronic disease outcome metadata in the included studies (n = 16)a.

From: Chronic disease outcome metadata from German observational studies – public availability and FAIR principles

Study

Publicly available chronic disease outcome metadata by source

(Meta-)data access infrastructure

Overall status

Scientific publications

Study website

Study/trial registries

Data documents

CARLA

All metadata described for some outcomes26,27,28,29,30,31

All metadata described (incl. links to scientific publications, data documents)32

Partial metadata described33

Data dictionaries; partial metadata described34

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (data dictionary) accessible without registration32

Complete metadata for all outcomes

DEGS1

Partial metadata described30,35,36

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications and data documents37

Not found

Variable list for all prevalent outcomes (baseline only); partial metadata described38

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (DEGS1 data dictionary) accessible without registration38

Partial metadata

DONALD

Partial metadata described39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46,47,48

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications49

Partial metadata described; links to website and scientific publications50,51,52,53

Not found

Availability: no

Partial metadata

EPIC-Heidelberg

All metadata described for some outcomes30,54,55,56,57,58,59,60,61,62,63,64,65

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications66,67

Not found

Not found

Availability: no; application process to obtain (meta-)data is described68

Complete metadata for some outcomes

EPIC- Potsdam

All metadata described for some outcomes30,55,56,69,70,71,72,73,74,75,76,77

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications67,78

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications50,51,52,53

Not found

Availability: no; application process to obtain data is described68

Complete metadata for some outcomes

GEDA 2009, 2010, 2012, 2014/2015, 2019/2020, 2021

All metadata described; questionnaires available as annex79,80,81,82

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications and data documents83,84

Not found

Variable list and questionnaire up to 2019/2020 with all metadata described38,79,82

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (data dictionary) accessible without registration38

Complete metadata for all outcomes

GHS

All metadata described for some outcomes30,85,86,87,88,89,90,91,92,93,94,95,96,97,98,99,100

Partial metadata described101

Not found

Not found

Availability: no

Complete metadata for some outcomes

GNHIES98 (BGS98)

Partial metadata described102

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications and data documents103

Not found

Variable list with partial metadata described38

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (data dictionary) accessible without registration38

Partial metadata

HCHS

Partial metadata described104,105,106,107

No metadata described; links to scientific publications105,108

Partial metadata described; links to website, scientific publications109

Not found

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: no (credentials needed; no registration option)110

Partial metadata

HNRS

Partial metadata described30,111,112,113,114,115,116,117,118,119,120,121,122

Partial metadata described123

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications124

Not found

Availability: no

Partial metadata

IDEFICS/ I.Family

All metadata described for some outcomes116,125,126,127,128

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications129,130,131

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications51,132,133

SOPs with partial metadata described125,134

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (SOPs, questionnaires) accessible after guest registration (temporary access)134

Complete metadata for some outcomes

KORA

Partial metadata described

refs. 30,135,136,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications

ref. 145

Partial metadata described

ref. 146

Variable lists with partial metadata described

ref. 147

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (variable lists) accessible after registration

ref. 147

Complete metadata for all outcomes

lidA

Partial metadata described148

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications149

Not found

Data reports with partial metadata150

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (reports with variable descriptions) accessible without registration150

Complete metadata for all outcomes

LIFE-Adult

Partial metadata described151,152,153

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications154

Partial metadata described; links to study website155

Data dictionaries with partial metadata156

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (data dictionaries) accessible after registration156

Partial metadata

NAKO

All metadata described for all outcomes157,158,159,160,161

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications162

Partial metadata described; links to study website linking to scientific publications163

Data dictionary with some metadata described164

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (data dictionary) accessible without registration; registration is also possible164

Complete metadata for all outcomes

SHIP/SHIP Trend

Partial metadata described30,165,166,167,168,169,170,171,172,173,174,175,176,177,178,179,180,181,182

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications and data documents183

Partial metadata described; links to scientific publications and study website33,53,146,163,184,185,186

Interview and study examination forms, data dictionaries with partial metadata described183,187

Availability: yes;

Accessibility: metadata (data dictionaries) accessible without registration187

Complete metadata for all outcomes

  1. aMetadata considered complete if all aspects of the chronic disease outcome metadata schema (Table 2) are covered for all examined cardiovascular diseases, type 2 diabetes, and cancers; metadata complete for “all outcomes” refers to the evaluation of these diseases only.