Table 1 Basic characteristics of patients included in the meta-analysis.
Author(year) | country, search duration | intervention (TDR/ACDF) | No. of patients (TDR/ACDF) | Mean age(years), female(%) | Number of cervical levels | FDA IDE trial | Follow up (months) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Anderson P. A.12 | Bryan disc/ACDF using allograft and a titanium alloy plate and screw | 242/221 | 1 level | YES | 36 | ||
Burkus J. K.13 | October 2002 to August 2004 | Prestige disc/ACDF using allograft with a plate | 276/265 | 43.59, 53.80 | 1 level | YES | 84 |
Coric D.15 | Kineflex C disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 136/133 | 43.80, 59.11 | 1 level | YES | 24 | |
Delamarter R. B.17 | US, August 2003 to October 2004 | ProDisc-C/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 103/106 | 42.81, 54.55 | 1 level | YES | 48 |
Garrido B. J.18 | Bryan disc/arthrodesis using allograft and a plate | 21/26 | 41.83, 36.16 | 1 level | NO | 48 | |
Heller J. G.19 | May 2002 to October 2004 | Bryan disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 242/221 | 44.54, 45.19 | 1 level | YES | 24 |
Hisey M. S.20 | US, April 2006 to March 2008 | Mobi-C disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate(SLIM-LOCTM/Sofamor Danek ATLANTISTM/ATLANTISTM VISION anterior cervical plate system) | 164/81 | 43.53, 53.47 | 1 level | YES | 48 |
Mummaneni P.22 | US, October 2002 to August 2004 | Prestige disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 276/265 | 43.59/53.80 | 1 level | YES | 24 |
Murrey D. B.23 | US, August 2003 to October 2004 | Prodisc-C disc/ACDF using allograft with a plate | 103/106 | 42.81, 54.55 | 1 level | YES | 24 |
Murrey D. B.24 | US, August 2003 to October 2004 | Prodisc-C disc/ACDF using allograft with a plate | 44/43 | 43.79, 44.83 | 1 level | YES | 24 |
Riew K. D.25 | US | Prestige ST disc/arthrodesis using allograft and a plate | 59/52 | 44.62, 54.95 | 1 level | YES | 24 |
US | Bryan disk/arthrodesis using allograft and a plate | 47/41 | 44.45, 62.50 | 1 level | YES | 24 | |
Riina j.26 | US | Prestige ST disc/ACDF using allograft with a plate | 10/9 | 1 level | YES | 24 | |
Sasso R. C.27 | Bryan disc/ACDF using allograft and ATLANTIS VISION plate | 56/59 | 44.35, 46.09 | 1 level | YES | 24 | |
Upadhyaya C. D.28 | US, | Prestige ST/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 253/220 | 43.58, 53.79 | 1 level | YES | 24 |
US, | Bryan Disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 230/194 | 44.54, 51.94 | 1 level | YES | 24 | |
US, | Prodisc-C disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 101/100 | 42.80, 54.55 | 1 level | YES | 24 | |
Zhang X.29 | China, May 2004 to May 2006 | Bryan Disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 60/60 | 45.17, 44.17 | 1 level | YES | 24 |
Zigler J. E.30 | August 2003 to October 2004 | ProDisc-C/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 103/106 | 42.81, 54.55 | 1 level | YES | 60 |
Davis R. J.16 | US, April 2006 to March 2008 | Mobi-C disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 225/105 | 45.59, 52.12 | 2 level | YES | 48 |
Coric D.14 | Bryan disc/ACDF using an allograft and a plate | 21/41 | not detailed | 1 or 2 level | YES | 24 | |
Kineflex C disc/ACDF using allograft and a plate | 16/41 | not detailed | 1 or 2 level | YES | 24 | ||
Jackson R. J.21 | Mobi-C disc/ACDF using allograft and Slim-Loc Anterior Cervical Plate System/Sofamor Danek Atlantis or Atlantis Vision Anterior Cervical Plate System | 179/81 | not detailed | 1 level | YES | 60 | |
Mobi-C disc/ACDF using allograft and Slim-Loc Anterior Cervical Plate System/Sofamor Danek Atlantis or Atlantis Vision Anterior Cervical Plate System | 234/105 | not detailed | 2 level | YES | 60 |
