Table 2 COD, TN, and P removal efficiencies and CH4 concentration in the upgraded biogas during the operational period evaluated.

From: Screening of microalgae for integral biogas slurry nutrient removal and biogas upgrading by different microalgae cultivation technology

Three microalgae strains/The mixed LED light wavelength treatments

COD Removal (%)

TN Removal (%)

TP Removal (%)

Concentration of CH4 (%, v/v)

Mono-cultivation of microalgae (cultures 1)

    

Chlorella vulgaris

68.93a ± 4.28

65.29b ± 5.34

64.39a ± 4.76

83.69a ± 5.31

Scenedesmus obliquus

70.27a ± 5.03

69.37a ± 4.83

62.55a ± 5.08

85.03a ± 3.28

Selenastrum capricornutum

61.04b ± 3.97

59.74c ± 5.27

57.33b ± 5.15

80.56b ± 4.74

Nitzschia palea

67.89a ± 5.31

67.86ab ± 4.96

61.29a ± 4.67

84.36a ± 4.57

Anabaena spiroides

63.75b ± 4.85

61.38c ± 5.39

56.11b ± 4.03

79.35b ± 3.73

Co-cultivation of microalgae with fungi (cultures 2)

    

Chlorella vulgaris

73.85ab ± 5.11

71.09ab ± 6.34

70.47a ± 5.62

89.78a ± 3.09

Scenedesmus obliquus

75.67a ± 5.78

74.57a ± 5.87

68.39 ab ± 4.39

90.35a ± 3.77

Selenastrum capricornutum

67.59bc ± 4.36

64.18c ± 4.39

59.88c ± 3.97

85.17b ± 2.78

Nitzschia palea

70.36b ± 6.09

69.66b ± 5.21

66.26b ± 5.79

88.39a ± 3.25

Anabaena spiroides

65.18c ± 4.65

63.37c ± 4.98

61.93c ± 4.31

84.39b ± 3.89

Co-cultivation of microalgae with activated sludge (cultures 3)

    

Chlorella vulgaris

70.82ab ± 4.73

75.26ab ± 6.32

68.73a ± 5.57

87.37ab ± 4.83

Scenedesmus obliquus

71.76a ± 5.71

76.44a ± 5.93

67.24a ± 4.39

90.79a ± 3.11

Selenastrum capricornutum

67.37b ± 5.06

70.69c ± 5.38

62.36b ± 5.32

88.68ab ± 3.27

Nitzschia palea

72.32a ± 5.47

73.43bc ± 4.65

65.67ab ± 4.08

91.06a ± 2.88

Anabaena spiroides

64.38c ± 4.58

69.08c ± 5.17

62.44b ± 5.43

83.83c ± 3.31

  1. Note: Values with different superscript letters for the same microalgae cultivation technology indicate a significant difference at P < 0.05 according to the Duncan’s multiple range tests.