Table 2 Univariable and multivariable meta-regression for outcome IS/AAR.

From: Optimization of large animal MI models; a systematic analysis of control groups from preclinical studies

Univariable Analysis

Multivariable analysis

Variable

categories

n

mean (95%CI)

p-value

post-hoc p-value

Variable

p-value

beta

post-hoc p-value

Species

Dog

122

46.4 (43.1–49.7)

<0.001

0.001 (pig vs dog)

Species

<0.001

+21.6 if pig (vs dog)

<0.001

Pig

41

59.3 (53.6–65.0)

0.552 (pig vs sheep)

+1.8 if pig (vs sheep)

0.874

Sheep

2

67.5 (41.0–93.9)

0.120 (dog vs sheep)

−19.8 if dog (vs sheep)

0.071

Sex

Male

45

47.7 (41.9–53.4)

0.80

All comparisons NS

Sex

0.07

+10.5 if male (vs female)

0.114

Female

11

50.0 (38.4–61.6)

+10.4 if male (vs unknown)

0.010

Both

78

51.3 (46.9–55.6)

−0.1 if female (vs unknown)

0.990

Unknown

31

49.5 (42.6–56.4)

+6.3 if male (vs both)

0.040

−4.1 if female (vs both)

0.491

+4.0 if both (vs unknown)

0.255

Immunosupp

not applicable

Immunosupp

not applicable

Comedication

yes

7

43.6 (29.2–58.0)

0.379

 

Comedication

0.01

−18.2 if used

 

no

158

50.2 (47.1–53.2)

Open vs closed model

Open

129

50.3 (46.9–53.7)

0.536

0.293 (open vs closed)

Open vs closed model

0.22

+4.9 if open (vs closed)

0.130

Closed

35

46.7 (40.2–53.3)

0.745 (open vs unknown)

−13.1 if open (vs unknown)

0.433

Unknown

1

57.0 (18.7–95.3)

0.603 (closed vs unknown)

−17.9 if closed (vs unknown)

0.287

Occlusion

Permanent

17

69.1 (60.5–77.7)

<0.001

<0.001 (permanent vs temporary)

Occlusion

<0.001

+36.3 if permanent (vs temporary)

<0.001

Temporary

145

47.2 (44.2–50.2)

0.072 (permanent vs unknown)

−9.2 if permament (vs unknown)

0.343

not known

3

65.9 (45.8–86.0)

0.774 (temporary vs unknown)

−45.7 if temporary (vs unknown)

<0.001

Occluded vessel

LAD

108

54.3 (50.8–57.7)

<0.001

<0.001 (LAD vs LCX)

Occluded vessel

0.03

+7.6 if LAD (vs LCX)

0.008

LCX

53

40.6 (35.6–45.6)

0.921 (LAD vs LAD/LCX)

+2.2 if LAD (vs LAD/LCX)

0.788

LAD/LCX

4

55.2 (36.9–73.5)

0.13 (LCX vs LAD/LCX)

−5.4 if LCX (vs LAD/LCX)

0.523

Quantification method

TTC

140

49.1 (45.8–52.3)

0.30

All comparisons NS

Quantification method

0.17

All comparisons NS

 

Nitro blue

10

60.6 (48.7–72.5)

      

Planimetry

11

48.6 (37.2–60.0)

      
 

Other§

4

54.1 (35.2–72.9)

      

Follow-up duration

165

−0.02/hour (−0.05–0.01)

0.12

 

Follow-up duration

0.011

−0.03/hour

 

Study Quality

165

+0.36/point (−1.7–2.4)

0.734

 

Study quality

0.945

+0.07/point

 

Ischemia time

145

−0.01/min (−0.07–0.05)

0.723

 

Ischemia time*(n = 56)

0.001

+0.09/min

 

Weight

159

+0.48/kg (0.219–0.743)

<0.001

 

Weight*(n = 159)

0.124

+0.25/kg

 

Age

5

−0.25/wk (−3.24–2.74)

0.806

 

Age*(n = 5)

not applicable

  1. §MRI, Fluoroluminescence, NADH Fluorescence or 111ln-Antimyosin. NS = non-significant. *Variable was added to the multivariable model separately, due to missing data. Total multivariable meta-regression was significant (p < 0.0001). n = the number of comparisons (=165 in total).