Table 2 Classical LA and models that generalize classical LA for partial agonism.

From: BIGL: Biochemically Intuitive Generalized Loewe null model for prediction of the expected combined effect compatible with partial agonism and antagonism

Method

Year published

biochemically interpretable

Comments

Tool

A. Classical Loewe (Concentration Additivity)

Loewe3

1926

✓

not applicable for marginal curves with different maximal effect

R package BIGL

B. LOF-test of null models

GCA (Howard)19

2009

 

assumes hill slope = 1 for the marginal curves

 

Scholze20

2014

 

rescales curves to common effect levels

 

FLM23

2016

 

special cases are compatible with Loewe

 

Loewe (Di Veroli)21

2016

 

reverts to highest single agent where classical Loewe is undefined

MATLAB Combenefit

BIGL

2017

✓

 

R package BIGL

C. Response surface capture models

Harbron22

2010

 

explores multiple null models

 

BRAID24

2016

 

BRAID additivity surface is not Loewe additive

R packages braidrm and braidReports