Table 1 Comprehensive list of potential causes for loss of optogenetic expression over time.
General Mechanism | Specific Mechanism | Description | Likely Singular Physical Manifestation | Evidence in Literature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Direct Nerve Damage | Phototoxicity | Light-induced thermal damage | Axonal death + Wallerian Degeneration | |
Cytotoxicity | Excitotoxicity | Optogenetic pore-induced electrostatic damage | Neuronal death via apoptosis | Beppu et al.15,Perny et al.16, Lignani et al.40, Feldbauer et al.41 |
ChR2 toxicity | Toxicity of opsin build-up & aggregation | Neuronal death via apoptosis | Zimmerman et al.9, Gradinaru et al.10, Miyashita et al.6, Li et al.42 | |
EYFP toxicity | Toxicity of reporter build-up & aggregation | Neuronal death via apoptosis | ||
Immunogenicity | AAV immunogenicity | Adaptive immune response to virus | Neuronal+ muscular death via CTL | Montgomery et al.1, Mingozzi et al.19, Sack et al.43, Kohro et al.17 |
ChR2 immunogenicity | Adaptive immune response to opsin | Neuronal death via CTL | None# | |
EYFP immunogenicity | Adaptive immune response to reporter | Neuronal death via CTL | ||
Protein Loss-of-Expression | Episomal DNA loss | rAAV DNA broken down or lost during division | Neuron likely healthy, no longer expresses | |
Epigenetic silencing | rAAV DNA silenced/methylated (no longer transcribed) | Neuron likely healthy, no longer expresses | ||
Transgene protein degradation or mRNA lysis/downregulation | Recombinant protein ubiquitinated and discarded via proteosome or no longer translated | Neuron likely healthy, no longer expresses | ||
Anatomical | Anatomical | More scattering in thick tissue | Neuron healthy, still expresses |