Table 1 Comprehensive list of potential causes for loss of optogenetic expression over time.

From: Optogenetic Peripheral Nerve Immunogenicity

General Mechanism

Specific Mechanism

Description

Likely Singular Physical Manifestation

Evidence in Literature

Direct Nerve Damage

Phototoxicity

Light-induced thermal damage

Axonal death + Wallerian Degeneration

Khan et al.13, Chen et al.39

Cytotoxicity

Excitotoxicity

Optogenetic pore-induced electrostatic damage

Neuronal death via apoptosis

Beppu et al.15,Perny et al.16, Lignani et al.40, Feldbauer et al.41

ChR2 toxicity

Toxicity of opsin build-up & aggregation

Neuronal death via apoptosis

Zimmerman et al.9, Gradinaru et al.10, Miyashita et al.6, Li et al.42

EYFP toxicity

Toxicity of reporter build-up & aggregation

Neuronal death via apoptosis

Ansari et al.22, Taghizadeh et al.24

Immunogenicity

AAV immunogenicity

Adaptive immune response to virus

Neuronal+ muscular death via CTL

Montgomery et al.1, Mingozzi et al.19, Sack et al.43, Kohro et al.17

ChR2 immunogenicity

Adaptive immune response to opsin

Neuronal death via CTL

None#

EYFP immunogenicity

Adaptive immune response to reporter

Neuronal death via CTL

Ansari et al.22, Stripecke et al.23 Kohro et al.17

Protein Loss-of-Expression

Episomal DNA loss

rAAV DNA broken down or lost during division

Neuron likely healthy, no longer expresses

McCarty et al.44, Fisher et al.45

Epigenetic silencing

rAAV DNA silenced/methylated (no longer transcribed)

Neuron likely healthy, no longer expresses

Robertson et al.46, Okada et al.47, Migliaccio et al.48

Transgene protein degradation or mRNA lysis/downregulation

Recombinant protein ubiquitinated and discarded via proteosome or no longer translated

Neuron likely healthy, no longer expresses

Jennings et al.49, Kong et al.50

Anatomical

Anatomical

More scattering in thick tissue

Neuron healthy, still expresses

Jacques et al.51, Maimon et al.4

  1. #Non-opsin transgene immunogenicity has been seen in AAV gene therapy19 and has been discussed as a concern for optogenetics52.