Table 1 Distribution of area attributes used to rank and match comparison areas to intervention areas.

From: Assessing effects from four years of industry-led badger culling in England on the incidence of bovine tuberculosis in cattle, 2013–2017

Area and zones

Area size km2

All TB incidents prior to the baseline date

OTF-W incidents prior to the baseline date

Number of herds

Herd size median

Distance to intervention area km

RBCT proactive %

Over 36 months

Over 12 months

Over 36 months

Over 12 months

Gloucestershire

  Intervention central

310.8

90

18

69

16

215

46.0

0.0

0.0

Comparison central (n = 9)

308.8

75.4

25.6

60.9

21.7

160.2

45.6

34.7

0.6

  Intervention buffer

143.2

41

17

29

11

94

47.0

0.0

0.3

  Comparison buffer (n = 9)

160.9

44.4

15.1

36.3

12.8

83.8

56.7

31.6

3.7

Somerset

  Intervention central

256.2

106

30

85

27

154

53.5

0.0

0.0

  Comparison central (n = 9)

255.7

76.4

27.1

61.7

22.1

162.1

52.8

60.3

0.0

  Intervention buffer

180.3

43

16

36

13

88

39.5

0.0

12.1

  Comparison buffer (n = 9)

133.2

38.2

13.4

29.6

10.9

84.3

60.3

60.3

2.0

Dorset

  Intervention central

223.3

80

26

57

17

157

100.0

0.0

0.0

  Comparison central (n = 8)

217.0

59.1

19.4

44.5

15.9

129.4

91.3

44.5

0.0

  Intervention buffer

172.2

37

10

23

8

113

95.0

0.0

0.0

  Comparison buffer (n = 8)

109.3

31.9

13.9

22.1

10.0

75.4

77.1

44.3

0.0

  1. Only OTF-W (Officially Tuberculosis Free Withdrawn, incidents of bovine tuberculosis (TB) in cattle herds with confirmatory evidence of Mycobacterium bovis infection from post-mortem tests) were used in matching of comparison areas. All TB incidents is OTF-W + OTF-S (OTF Suspended, which are TB incidents without confirmatory evidence of M. bovis infection from post-mortem tests). Comparison area values are means for 9, 9 and 8 areas for Somerset, Gloucestershire and Dorset respectively. Comparison areas for Somerset and Gloucestershire are the same as those reported in Brunton et al.11 but reduced by one for each area due to overlap of new interventions licensed in 2015 and 2016. Two Dorset comparison areas were lost due to overlapping intervention areas licensed in 2016. Values for each area are reported in the Supplement.