Table 7 Robustness test of main effect and intermediary effect when dependent variable is NPS.

From: Environmental regulations, green innovation and intelligent upgrading of manufacturing enterprises: evidence from China

Variable

Model 23

Model 24

Model 25

Model 26

Model 27

Model 28

ER

 

0.347*** (2.87)

 

0.375*** (3.02)

 

0.268** (2.13)

GI

    

0.405*** (3.16)

0.319*** (2.73)

ED

      

GI × ED

      

INUU

0.117 (1.34)

0.102 (1.15)

0.171* (1.89)

0.163* (1.73)

0.279** (2.47)

0.155 (1.42)

ES

0.125 (1.41)

0.124 (1.38)

0.175* (1.77)

0.162* (1.70)

0.119 (1.25)

0.132 (1.54)

BA

0.236** (2.38)

− 0.196* (− 1.76)

0.205** (1.97)

− 0.211** (− 2.13)

0.235** (2.18)

0.223** (2.07)

AL

0.116 (1.35)

0.107 (1.02)

0.152

(1.24)

− 0.149 (− 1.17)

0.197* (1.68)

0.187* (1.66)

Individual factor

Control

Control

Control

Control

Control

Control

Time factor

Control

Control

Control

Control

Control

Control

Constant

0.196* (1.92)

0,181* (1.83)

0.241** (2.26)

0.221** (2.12)

0.201** (2.05)

0.218** (2.09)

R2

0.271

0.262

0.327

0.307

0.337

0.267

F

22.07***

20.35***

26.17***

25.06***

23.81***

21. 49***

  1. ***, ** and * respectively indicate that the parameter estimation is significant at the levels of 0.01, 0.05 and 0.1. The "t" value is in parentheses.