Table 4 Comprehensive assessment ranking of the expression stability for the eight candidate reference genes.
Methods | Ranking | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | |
Rhizosheath development | ||||||||
NormFinder | elF | HIS-3 | GADPH | TIP41 | PP2A | ARP6 | ALDH | α-TUB |
geNorm | TIP411/GADPH | elF | PP2A | ARP6 | ALDH | HIS-3 | α-TUB |  |
Bestkeeper | elF | PP2A | TIP411 | ARP6 | GADPH | HIS-3 | ALDH | α-TUB |
∆CT | elF | GADPH | TIP411 | PP2A | ARP6 | HIS-3 | ALDH | α-TUB |
Comprehensive assessment | elF | GADPH | TIP411 | PP2A | HIS-3 | ARP6 | ALDH | α-TUB |
Drought | ||||||||
NormFinder | GADPH | elF | TIP41 | ARP6 | ALDH | α-TUB | PP2A | HIS-3 |
geNorm | elF/TIP41 | GADPH | ARP6 | ALDH | α-TUB | PP2A | HIS-3 |  |
Bestkeeper | GADPH | ALDH | elF | ARP6 | TIP41 | α-TUB | PP2A | HIS-3 |
∆CT | GADPH | elF | TIP411 | ARP6 | ALDH | α-TUB | PP2A | HIS-3 |
Comprehensive assessment | GADPH | elF | TIP41 | ARP6 | ALDH | α-TUB | PP2A | HIS-3 |
Tissues | ||||||||
NormFinder | ARP6 | ALDH | TIP41 | PP2A | elF | GADPH | HIS-3 | α-TUB |
geNorm | TIP41/ALDH | ARP6 | PP2A | elF | GADPH | HIS-3 | α-TUB |  |
Bestkeeper | TIP411 | ALDH | ARP6 | HIS-3 | PP2A | elF | GADPH | α-TUB |
∆CT | ARP6 | PP2A | ALDH | elF | TIP411 | GADPH | HIS-3 | α-TUB |
Comprehensive assessment | ARP6 | ALDH | TIP41 | PP2A | elF | GADPH | HIS-3 | α-TUB |
All samples | ||||||||
NormFinder | ARP6 | ALDH | elF | PP2A | TIP41 | GADPH | HIS-3 | α-TUB |
geNorm | elF/GADPH | PP2A | ARP6 | ALDH | TIP41 | HIS-3 | α-TUB |  |
Bestkeeper | TIP41 | ARP6 | elF | PP2A | ALDH | GADPH | HIS-3 | α-TUB |
∆CT | ARP6 | elF | PP2A | ALDH | GADPH | TIP41 | HIS-3 | α-TUB |
Comprehensive assessment | ARP6 | elF | PP2A | ALDH | GADPH | TIP41 | HIS-3 | α-TUB |
