Table 1 Performance evaluation of the spinal radiographic parameters of the ensemble model.

From: Deep learning approach for automatic landmark detection and alignment analysis in whole-spine lateral radiographs

Radiographic parameters

Ground truth

Parameter error†

Correlation analysis

Wilcoxon signed-rank test

Mean (SD)

Mean (SD)

Median (IQR)

R

p value

p value

PI

51.6° (13.1°)

3.8° (5.7°)

1.9° (3.3°)

0.854

 < 0.001*

0.587

SS

35.9° (12.1°)

3.5° (4.8°)

1.9° (3.0°)

0.875

0.578

PT

15.6° (11.0°)

1.1° (1.7°)

0.6° (0.9°)

0.983

0.430

LL

47.0° (17.4°)

5.1° (6.3°)

3.0° (4.7°)

0.885

0.145

SVA (mm)

25.2 (47.3)

1.9 (2.4)

1.0 (1.9)

0.998

0.402

CL

9.4° (17.3°)

6.6° (6.0°)

5.3° (6.4°)

0.864

0.636

T1S

24.4° (11.3°)

5.3° (5.1°)

3.8° (4.7°)

0.787

0.002*

cSVA (mm)

20.2 (13.4)

1.1 (1.4)

0.7 (1.0)

0.991

0.769

GTK

37.7° (14.4°)

6.6° (6.2°)

4.9° (6.5°)

0.798

0.029*

PTK

13.7° (9.7°)

6.7° (6.2°)

4.8° (6.5°)

0.558

0.013*

MTK

26.7° (13.5°)

5.4° (5.0°)

4.2° (5.6°)

0.840

0.726

L4SL

31.3° (11.5°)

4.3° (5.3°)

2.3° (4.2°)

0.810

0.133

LPA

8.3° (8.3°)

1.0° (1.7°)

0.5° (0.8°)

0.971

0.370

SSA

124.4° (14.8°)

3.4° (4.7°)

1.9° (3.0°)

0.919

0.480

GT

17.2° (15.0°)

1.2° (2.0°)

0.6° (1.0°)

0.988

0.636

TPA

13.1° (12.0°)

1.0° (1.6°)

0.5° (0.8°)

0.987

0.814

Barrey index

0.4 (3.1)

0.3 (1.5)

0.03 (0.1)

0.893

0.489

OD-HA

āˆ’Ā 0.4° (3.9°)

0.1° (0.2°)

0.1° (0.1°)

0.999

0.167

  1. R Pearson correlation coefficient; SD standard deviation; IQR interquartile range, PI pelvic incidence; SS sacral slope; PT pelvic tilt; LL lumbar lordosis; SVA sagittal vertical axis; CL cervical lordosis; T1S T1 slope; cSVA cervical sagittal vertical axis; GTK global thoracic kyphosis; PTK proximal thoracic kyphosis; MTK main thoracic kyphosis; L4SL L4-S1 lordosis; LPA lumbar pelvic angle; SSA spino-sacral angle; GT global tilt; TPA T1 pelvic angle; OD-HA odontoid hip axis.
  2. *p value < 0.05.
  3. †Absolute difference between the prediction and the ground truth.