Table 3 Risk-of-Bias assessment of included studies.

From: Dose–response effects of light therapy on sleepiness and circadian phase shift in shift workers: a meta-analysis and moderator analysis

Study

Random sequence generation

Allocation concealment

Blinding of participants and personnel

Blinding of outcome assessment

Incomplete outcome data

Selective reporting

Babkoff 2002

U

U

H

L

H

L

Bjorvatn 2007

U

U

U

U

H

L

Bjorvatn 2020

U

L

L

U

H

L

Boivin 2012

U

U

U

U

L

H

Comtet 2019

L

U

U

U

L

L

Dawson 1991

U

U

U

U

L

L

Dawson 1995

U

U

L

U

L

L

Griepentrog 2018

H

U

U

U

L

L

Horowitz 2001

U

U

U

U

L

L

Karchani 2011

U

U

U

U

L

L

Kretschmer 2013

U

U

U

U

L

L

Lee 2006

U

U

U

U

L

L

Lee 2020

U

U

U

U

L

L

Lowden 2004

U

U

H

U

L

L

Nagashima 2017

U

U

U

U

L

L

Sadeghniiat-Haghighi 2011

U

U

U

U

L

L

Smith 2009

U

U

U

L

L

L

Sunde 2020

U

U

U

U

H

L

Tanaka 2011

L

L

H

U

L

L

Thorne 2010

U

U

H

U

H

L

Yoon 2002

U

U

U

U

L

L

  1. L low risk, H high risk, U unclear risk.