Table 1 State of the art of flexible, steerable instruments for endoscopic maxillary sinus surgery.

From: A miniature robotic steerable endoscope for maxillary sinus surgery called PliENT

Author

Illustration

Tools

Diameter

Performance characteristics

Control

Yoon et al.29

Camera

4 mm

1 DOF; 180° BA; 9.5 mm BR

Teleoperation

Yoon et al.29

Gripper

5 mm

2 DOF; 180° BA; 9.5 mm BR

Teleoperation

Rosen et al.30

2 scanning fiber, forceps, scissors, irrigation channel

8 mm

3 DOF; 180° BA

Teleoperation

Hong et al.31

Gripper

4 mm

1 DOF; 270° BA; 10 mm BR

Teleoperation

Webster et al.32

–

0.8–2.4 mm

6 DOF

Teleoperation

3NT Medical Ltd28

Irrigation channel, camera

2.3 mm

1 DOF (1.dir); 125° BA; 3 mm BR

Manual (2 hands)

Endius Inc.33

Forceps

3 mm

1 DOF (1.dir); 180° BA

Manual (2 hands)

Smith & Nephew34

Forceps

3 mm

1 DOF; 240° BA

Manual (2 hands)

  1. For the performance characteristics, the number of degree of freedom (DOF), the bending angle (BA) and the bending radius (BR) of each instrument is indicated when mentioned by the authors.