Table 3 Proposed significance of variables in final model of prediction of future AFB risk.

From: Establishment of apiary-level risk of American foulbrood through the detection of Paenibacillus larvae spores in pooled, extracted honey in Saskatchewan

Variable category

Variable

Explanation of odds ratio

Proposed significance for beekeepers

Demographic

Beekeeper Size

The odds of being in a higher AFB risk category are greater for large-scale beekeepers than for small-scale beekeepers

Potential selection bias during beekeeper enrolment

Large size of operations may increase likelihood of close proximity to sources of spores

General Management

Indoor Overwintering of Hives

The odds of being in a higher AFB risk category are greater for beekeepers overwintering a large proportion of hives indoors than beekeepers overwintering fewer hives indoors

Biosecuirty must be considered with indoor overwintering

Return colonies to apiaries they are collected from; identify hives for traceability

Reduce any tendency toward the indoor overwintering of weak colonies

Purchase of Used Equipment

The odds of being in a higher AFB risk category are greater for beekeepers that have purchased used equipment than for those beekeepers who have not

Minimize the purchase of used equipment whenever possible

If used equipment must be purchased, ensure professional inspection and/or testing

Ensure appropriate quarantine and identification to improve traceability

Prevention of AFB

Current Antibiotic Use

The odds of being in a higher AFB risk category are greater for those beekeepers that are currently using or have recently used antimicrobials than for those that have never used antimicrobials or have not used them recently

Current or recent use likely reflective of recent experience with or known risk of AFB

Confidence in AFB Recognition

The odds of being in a higher AFB risk category are greater for beekeepers that are very confident at recognizing AFB than those that are somewhat or not confident at recognizing AFB

Ability to recognize AFB likely reflective of previous experience with AFB

Movement of Colonies between Apiaries

The odds of being in a higher AFB risk category are greater for beekeepers that move honey-producing colonies between apiaries than those who do not

Minimize the movement of honey-producing colonies between apiaries whenever possible

If colonies must be moved, ensure appropriate identification to improve traceability