Table 3 Death before anti-TB treatment among pulmonary TB patients with and without NAA test.

From: Nucleic acid amplification tests reduce delayed diagnosis and misdiagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis

 

No NAA

With NAA

p valuea

NAA strategy

p valueb

p valuec

p valued

Frontline NAA

Add-on NAA

Overall population

Case number

1193

999

 

282

717

   

Death before treatment

53 (4.4%)

16 (1.6%)

 < 0.001

2 (0.7%)

14 (2.0%)

0.003

0.004

0.159

Smear-positive cohort

Case number

222

750

 

188

562

   

Death before treatment

3 (1.4%)

11 (1.5%)

0.368

1 (0.5%)

10 (1.8%)

0.400

0.672

0.308

Smear-negative cohort

Case number

971

249

 

94

155

   

Death before treatment

50 (5.1%)

5 (2.0%)

0.033

1 (1.1%)

4 (2.6%)

0.077

0.165

0.653

  1. Data are presented as n (%).
  2. NAA nucleic acid amplification, TB tuberculosis.
  3. aComparison between patients with and without NAA tests.
  4. bComparison between patients with frontline NAA and no NAA test.
  5. cComparison between patients with add-on NAA and no NAA test.
  6. dComparison between patients with frontline and add-on NAA test.