Table 2 Summary of the selected papers on the economic growth-energy consumption relationship.
From: The trilemma among CO2 emissions, energy use, and economic growth in Russia
Author(s) | Country | Period | Methodology | Supported hypothesis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Lee and Chang (2008) | 16 Asian countries | 1971–2002 | Panel model | Neutrality, growth |
Narayan and Smyth (2008) | G7-countries | 1972–2002 | Panel model | Growth |
Belloumi (2009) | Tunisia | 1971–2004 | VAR | Feedback |
Sadorsky (2009) | 18 emerging countries | 1994–2003 | Panel cointegration, FMOLS | Conservation |
Menyah and Wolde-Rufael (2010) | USA | 1960–2007 | VAR | Conservation |
Apergis and Payne (2010a) | 20 OECD countries | 1985–2005 | FMOLS | Growth |
Apergis and Payne (2010b) | 13 Eurasian countries | 1992–2007 | Panel model | Growth |
Ocal and Aslan (2013) | Turkey | 1990–2010 | Toda-Yamamoto causality | Conservation |
Pao and Fu (2013) | Brazil | 1980–2010 | Cointegration, ECM | Feedback |
Bilgili and Ozturk (2015) | G7 countries | 1980–2009 | Panel model | Growth |
Magazzino (2015) | Italy | 1970–2009 | VAR, VECM | Growth |
Ozturk and Bilgili (2015) | 51 SSA countries | 1980–2009 | Panel model | Growth |
Pao and Fu (2015) | Mexico | 2980–2011 | Lotka-Volterra model | Neutrality |
Aslan (2016) | USA | 1961–2011 | ARDL | Growth |
Adams et al. (2018) | 30 SSA countries | 1980–2012 | DOLS-FMOLS | Growth |
Ntanos et al. (2018) | 25 European countries | 2007–2016 | Panel model | Growth |
Luqman et al. (2019) | Pakistan | 1990–2016 | NARDL | Growth |
Shahbaz et al. (2020) | 38 REC countries | 1990–2018 | DOLS, FMOLS | Growth |
Acheampong et al. (2021) | 23 emerging economies | 1970–2015 | IV-GMM | Feedback |
Gyimah et al. (2022) | Ghana | 1990–2015 | GC | Growth |
Espoir et al. (2023) | African countries | 1980–2018 | Panel model | Growth |
Lawal (2023) | Africa | 1980–2019 | Frequency domain analysis | Feedback |
Mohammadi et al. (2023) | Selected developed and developing countries f | 1993–2019 | FMOLS Dumitrescu and Hurlin heterogeneous panel causality | Growth |
Simionescu (2023) | 13 EU countries | 2002–2021 | Panel model | Feedback, growth |
