Table 1 Synopsis of demographics, referring departments, patient history, and principal diagnoses and treatment recommendations as well as a brief statement on whether the treatment recommendations were considered problematic. Abbreviations: AC—acromioclavicular, ACL—anterior cruciate ligament, ALPSA—anterior labroligamentous periosteal sleeve avulsion of the labrum, ER—emergency department, GH—glenohumeral, GLAD—glenolabral articular disruption, GP—general practitioner, HAGL—humeral avulsion of the glenohumeral ligament, INT—Internal Medicine, ISP—infraspinatus, OTS—orthopedic and trauma surgery, PCL—posterior cruciate ligament, PED – Pediatrics, PS—Plastic Surgery, RD—Referring department, SSC—subscapularis, SSP – supraspinatus. Supplementary Tables 1 and 2 provide further details on the reported diagnoses and treatment recommendations, respectively.

From: A pilot study on the efficacy of GPT-4 in providing orthopedic treatment recommendations from MRI reports

MRI Study

Age

Sex

Referral

Reason for exam

Principal reported diagnoses

Principal treatment recommendation

Treatment recommendation(s) problematic?

Knee

1

75

Male

INT

Undulating fever and swollen and painful knee

Joint infection with concomitant osteomyelitis and advanced degeneration

Address infection and inflammation (antibiotics) after blood tests

Yes

2

68

Male

OTS

Worsening symptoms. Medial osteoarthritis

Medial compartmental osteoarthritis with bone changes and meniscus degeneration and chondropathy elsewhere in the joint

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No

3

62

Male

OTS

Medial pain since fall several weeks ago

Insufficiency fracture of the medial femoral condyle and cartilage intact

Rest and avoid weight-bearing. Use crutches or cane

Yes

4

62

Male

GP

Clinical suspicion of medial meniscus lesion

Horizontal posterior root tear of the medial meniscus

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

Yes

5

52

Female

ED

Joint pain since fall

Medial meniscus tear of posterior horn

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No

6

48

Male

OTS

S/p knee dislocation. After reduction

Rupture of the ACL, medial collateral ligament, bucket handle tear of the medial meniscus (O'Donoghue triad), and rupture of the PCL, medial retinaculum, and popliteus muscle

Surgery. Conservative measures while waiting for surgery

Yes

7

31

Female

OTS

Clinical suspicion of ACL or meniscus damage after skiing accident

Partial rupture/overstretching of the proximal ACL and the MCL. Tibial bone bruise

Conservative measures

No

8

25

Female

OTS

Radiographic suspicion of bony avulsion of ACL

Bony avulsion of the ACL, impression fracture of the tibial plateau, and radial tear of the lateral meniscus posterior horn

Surgery

Yes

9

14

Male

PED

S/p ACL reconstruction. Pain after knee distortion during fall

Partial ACL graft rupture and s/p lateral patellar dislocation

Conservative measures

Yes

10

14

Female

PED

Regular follow-up

Constant osteochondroma of the distal femur (cartilage cap: 0.5 cm)

No treatment if asymptomatic. Surgical removal if symptomatic

Yes

Shoulder

1

68

Female

OTS

Palpable mass over shoulder. No pain

Subcutaneous lipoma and advanced attritive changes of the glenohumeral joint (rheumatic disease)

Conservative measures

Yes

2

68

Female

GP

Impingement syndrome

Degenerative changes of the GH and AC joints. Partial ruptures of the SSP and SSC tendons

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

Yes

3

63

Male

OTS

Clinical suspicion of calcific tendinitis. Biceps pathology?

Calcific tendinitis and ISP tendinopathy

Conservative measures

No

4

61

Male

OTS

S/p second dislocation

Hill-Sachs lesion, glenoid bone loss of 8%, HAGL and GLAD lesions

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No

5

60

Male

OTS

Traumatic injury three months ago with supraspinatus tendon tear on ultrasound

Massive rotator cuff tear involving SSP, SSC, and ISP tendons with volume atrophy and fatty infiltration, as well as activated AC joint arthritis

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No

6

60

Male

OTS

Acute-on-chronic shoulder pain. Post-instability osteoarthritis

Advanced osteoarthritis of GH and AC joints with SSP and ISP tendinopathy

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No

7

34

Male

GP

S/p second dislocation

Hill-Sachs lesion, glenoid bone loss of 15%, ALPSA and GLAD lesions

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No

8

47

Female

GP

Clinical suspicion of adhesive capsulitis

Adhesive capsulitis

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No

9

32

Male

PS

Palpable swelling over the shoulder. No pain

No pathology, just a strong muscular build

Conservative measures

No

10

53

Female

INT

Impingement syndrome for six months. Loss of abduction strength

Intratendinous lesion of SSP tendon with bursitis

Conservative measures. If failing, surgical measures

No