Table 29 Summary of the p-value of the posthoc_nemenyi_friedman test evaluated over all runs (sampling).

From: Efficient implicit constraint handling approaches for constrained optimization problems

Performance indicator

Sampling

Real_lhs

Real_random

Hybrid-cvtol vs. BU

Hybrid-cvtol vs. Without BU

BU vs. Without BU

Hybrid-cvtol vs. BU

Hybrid-cvtol vs. Without BU

BU vs. Without BU

p-value

ha

p-value

h

p-value

h

p-value

h

p-value

h

p-value

h

IGD

0.04

+

0.09

~

0.90

~

0.06

~

0.01

+

0.90

~

IGD+

0.04

+

0.02

+

0.90

~

0.12

~

0.03

+

0.90

~

GD

0.01

+

0.06

~

0.90

~

0.06

~

0.01

+

0.90

~

GD+

0.01

+

0.06

~

0.90

~

0.06

~

0.01

+

0.90

~

  1. aPosthoc_nemenyi_friedman: +, ~, and – presents the first method performs statistically significantly better, equal, and worse than the second approach.