Table 7 Classification accuracy with standard deviation comparison with other state of art bireduct algorithms.

From: Covering assisted intuitionistic fuzzy bi-selection technique for data reduction and its applications

Dataset

Classifier

RBR

IFBR

CFBR

Proposed method

Bank

JRip

86.44\(\pm 3.22^4\)

89.65\(\pm 2.31^2\)

88.12\(\pm 2.32^3\)

90.27\(\pm 1.15^1\)

Marketing

RF

89.23\(\pm 3.25^4\)

90.22\(\pm 3.01^3\)

91.59\(\pm 2.65^2\)

94.37\(\pm 1.01^1\)

Hepatitis

JRip

86.19\(\pm 6.52^4\)

89.24\(\pm 8.31^1\)

87.23\(\pm 8.11^3\)

89.14\(\pm 7.67^2\)

 

RF

92.34\(\pm 5.98^1\)

90.34\(\pm 7.22^3\)

89.44\(\pm 7.97^4\)

91.86\(\pm 7.22^2\)

dbworld

JRip

86.41\(\pm 10.24^4\)

87.12\(\pm 11.21^3\)

89.21\(\pm 12.56^2\)

91.74\(\pm 10.08^1\)

Bodies

RF

89.32\(\pm 9.65^4\)

90.54\(\pm 9.98^3\)

91.32\(\pm 10.87^2\)

93.93\(\pm 8.32^1\)

Arcene

JRip

81.27\(\pm 11.12^3\)

80.31\(\pm 8.78^4\)

82.21\(\pm 9.95^2\)

84.32\(\pm 9.07^1\)

 

RF

84.27\(\pm 9.32^3\)

84.23\(\pm 7.98^4\)

87.65\(\pm 7.43^2\)

90.58\(\pm 6.99^1\)

Mushroom

JRip

92.68\(\pm 2.71^3\)

91.12\(\pm 4.37^4\)

93.89\(\pm 2.21^2\)

99.95\(\pm 0.13^1\)

 

RF

95.44\(\pm 1.51^3\)

95.21\(\pm 1.86^4\)

97.28\(\pm 1.09^2\)

99.99\(\pm 0.04^1\)

qsarbio-degradation

JRip

84.80\(\pm 3.87^{2.5}\)

85.54\(\pm 2.54^1\)

82.21\(\pm 2.89^4\)

84.80\(\pm 3.87^{2.5}\)

 

RF

89.45\(\pm 3.23^3\)

90.62\(\pm 3.87^2\)

86.29\(\pm 2.98^4\)

92.63\(\pm 2.43^1\)

Fertility diagonsis

JRip

75.59\(\pm 10.01^{4}\)

81.41\(\pm 10.18^2\)

83.17\(\pm 9.99^1\)

78.44\(\pm 9.68^{3}\)

 

RF

81.43\(\pm 9.73 ^4\)

86.23\(\pm 11.21^{2.5}\)

86.23\(\pm 11.21^{2.5}\)

89.04\(\pm 10.28^1\)

Ionosphere

JRip

91.21\(\pm 3.95^4\)

95.55\(\pm 3.78^{1.5}\)

92.45\(\pm 4.11^3\)

95.55\(\pm 3.78^{1.5}\)

 

RF

95.31\(\pm 3.01^4\)

98.12\(\pm 2.67^{1.5}\)

96.29\(\pm 3.19^3\)

98.12\(\pm 2.67^{1.5}\)

Thyroid-hypothyroid

JRip

92.41\(\pm 2.19^3\)

91.46\(\pm 1.65^4\)

98.22\(\pm 1.05^2\)

99.32\(\pm 0.47^1\)

 

RF

95.41\(\pm 2.01^3\)

93.59\(\pm 2.86^4\)

99.11\(\pm 0.98^2\)

99.59\(\pm 0.36^1\)

wdbc

JRip

95.21\(\pm 2.98^{3.5}\)

95.21\(\pm 2.98^{3.5}\)

96.20\(\pm 2.47^{1.5}\)

96.20\(\pm 2.47^{1.5}\)

 

RF

96.79\(\pm 3.02^3\)

96.28\(\pm 1.86^4\)

97.86\(\pm 2.21^{1.5}\)

97.86\(\pm 2.21^{1.5}\)

Average

JRip

3.50

2.60

2.35

1.55

Rank

RF

3.20

3.10

2.50

1.20

F statistics

JRip

5.68

   
 

RF

9.29

  Â