Table 3 Main results. The results marked with the asterisks are based on our reproduction. A bold number denotes the highest value in that column. The Bold is the best results.

From: Semantic-enhanced graph neural network for named entity recognition in ancient Chinese books

Groups

Methods

P

R

F

Without dictionary

CNN-CRF

56.61

57.12

56.86

BiLSTM-CRF

56.82

57.2

57.01

TENER

57.42

59.36

58.37

BAC-CRF

66.12

76.42

70.89

With dictionary

LR-CNN

60.62

63.65

62.10

Lattice-LSTM

60.14

62.42

61.26

NFLAT

62.86

64.09

63.47

Ours

BAC-GNN-CRF

70.98

78.86

74.71