Table 2 Comparison of CPU computation times on A-set benchmark instances.
From: A discrete wild horse optimizer for capacitated vehicle routing problem
Instance | DWHO | BWHO | Hybrid firefly algorithm | DSRACO | DAEO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
A-n32-k5 | 179.90 | 9.48 | 865.76 | 756.58 | 934.97 |
A-n33-k5 | 595.53 | 9.94 | 852.87 | 785.02 | 984.78 |
A-n33-k6 | 222.41 | 10.54 | 901.95 | 833.78 | 958.23 |
A-n34-k5 | 220.04 | 9.73 | 959.46 | 847.27 | 1052.58 |
A-n36-k5 | 331.14 | 10.19 | 705.90 | 922.30 | 1988.15 |
A-n37-k5 | 231.17 | 9.91 | 1138.60 | 907.14 | 1518.48 |
A-n37-k6 | 1141.95 | 9.92 | 1122.42 | 936.97 | 1205.51 |
A-n38-k5 | 843.99 | 10.69 | 1131.73 | 874.89 | 1227.59 |
A-n39-k5 | 260.99 | 10.09 | 1169.42 | 980.69 | 1250.25 |
A-n39-k6 | 135.97 | 10.73 | 1110.46 | 943.51 | 1280.44 |
A-n44-k6 | 432.67 | 10.37 | 1747.36 | 1241.72 | 1444.91 |
A-n45-k6 | 624.79 | 10.02 | 1328.35 | 932.24 | 1518.48 |
A-n46-k7 | 448.42 | 10.51 | 1443.90 | 1294.92 | 1605.48 |
A-n48-k7 | 1085.85 | 10.44 | 1536.31 | 1216.80 | 1703.76 |
A-n53-k7 | 448.24 | 10.69 | 1831.94 | 1199.11 | 1978.63 |
A-n54-k7 | 1806.04 | 10.90 | 1742.13 | 1446.63 | 2320.62 |
A-n60-k9 | 2140.09 | 10.98 | 1948.91 | 1304.45 | 2320.62 |
A-n63-k10 | 1832.02 | 11.13 | 2308.13 | 1453.48 | 2401.92 |
A-n65-k9 | 1607.52 | 11.72 | 2165.56 | 1229.31 | 2394.17 |
A-n80-k10 | 3007.99 | 11.56 | 3082.98 | 1613.03 | 3218.99 |
