Table 3 Comparison of absolute errors for \(\Phi (\chi ,\tau )\) and \(\Psi (\chi ,\tau )\) in Problem 2 when \(\xi =2\), \(\zeta =2\), \(\mu =1\).

From: Analytical solutions for the Noyes Field model of the time fractional Belousov Zhabotinsky reaction using a hybrid integral transform technique

\(\chi\)

\(\tau\)

\(|\Phi ^{\texttt{Exact}}-\Phi ^{\texttt{C}}|\)

\(|\Phi ^{\texttt{Exact}}-\Phi ^{\texttt{CF}}|\)

\(|\Phi ^{\texttt{Exact}}-\Phi ^{\texttt{AB}}|\)

FRDTM34

q-HATM34

0

0.01

2.71078\(e-12\)

2.71033\(e-12\)

2.71078\(e-12\)

2.71072\(e-12\)

2.07040\(e-12\)

0.03

6.73927\(e-10\)

6.73926\(e-10\)

6.73927\(e-10\)

6.73927\(e-10\)

6.73927\(e-10\)

0.05

8.86033\(e-09\)

8.86033\(e-09\)

8.86033\(e-09\)

8.86033\(e-09\)

8.86033\(e-09\)

1

0.01

3.21043\(e-12\)

3.21060\(e-12\)

3.21043\(e-12\)

3.21052\(e-12\)

3.21051\(e-12\)

0.03

7.72406\(e-10\)

7.72406\(e-10\)

7.72406\(e-10\)

7.72406\(e-10\)

7.72406\(e-10\)

0.05

9.82970\(e-09\)

9.82970\(e-09\)

9.82970\(e-09\)

9.82970\(e-09\)

9.82970\(e-09\)

2

0.01

3.00746\(e-12\)

3.00693\(e-12\)

3.00746\(e-12\)

3.00748\(e-12\)

3.00748\(e-12\)

0.03

7.36736\(e-10\)

7.36735\(e-10\)

7.36736\(e-10\)

7.36736\(e-10\)

7.36736\(e-10\)

0.05

9.54952\(e-09\)

9.54953\(e-09\)

9.54952\(e-09\)

9.54952\(e-09\)

9.54952\(e-09\)

3

0.01

4.48808\(e-13\)

4.48114\(e-13\)

4.48808\(e-13\)

4.48808\(e-13\)

4.48808\(e-13\)

0.03

1.13509\(e-10\)

1.13508\(e-10\)

1.13509\(e-10\)

1.13509\(e-10\)

1.13509\(e-10\)

0.05

1.51797\(e-09\)

1.51797\(e-09\)

1.51797\(e-09\)

1.51797\(e-09\)

1.51797\(e-09\)

4

0.01

5.04097\(e-13\)

5.04558\(e-13\)

5.04097\(e-13\)

5.04100\(e-13\)

5.04100\(e-13\)

0.03

1.21954\(e-10\)

1.21955\(e-10\)

1.21954\(e-10\)

1.21954\(e-10\)

1.21954\(e-10\)

0.05

1.56086\(e-09\)

1.56086\(e-09\)

1.56086\(e-09\)

1.56086\(e-09\)

1.56086\(e-09\)

  

\(|\Psi ^{\texttt{Exact}}-\Psi ^{\texttt{C}}|\)

\(|\Psi ^{\texttt{Exact}}-\Psi ^{\texttt{CF}}|\)

\(|\Psi ^{\texttt{Exact}}-\Psi ^{\texttt{AB}}|\)

FRDTM34

q-HATM34

0

0.01

1.35539\(e-12\)

1.35547\(e-12\)

1.35539\(e-12\)

1.35536\(e-12\)

1.35536\(e-12\)

0.03

3.36964\(e-10\)

3.36964\(e-10\)

3.36964\(e-10\)

3.36964\(e-10\)

3.36964\(e-10\)

0.05

4.43017\(e-09\)

4.43017\(e-09\)

4.43017\(e-09\)

4.43017\(e-09\)

4.43017\(e-09\)

1

0.01

1.60522\(e-12\)

1.60510\(e-12\)

1.60522\(e-12\)

1.60526\(e-12\)

1.60526\(e-12\)

0.03

3.86203\(e-10\)

3.86203\(e-10\)

3.86203\(e-10\)

3.86203\(e-10\)

3.86203\(e-10\)

0.05

4.91485\(e-09\)

4.91485\(e-09\)

4.91485\(e-09\)

4.91485\(e-09\)

4.91485\(e-09\)

2

0.01

1.50373\(e-12\)

1.50362\(e-12\)

1.50373\(e-12\)

1.50374\(e-12\)

1.50374\(e-12\)

0.03

3.68368\(e-10\)

3.68368\(e-10\)

3.68368\(e-10\)

3.68368\(e-10\)

3.68368\(e-10\)

0.05

4.77476\(e-09\)

4.77476\(e-09\)

4.77476\(e-09\)

4.77476\(e-09\)

4.77476\(e-09\)

3

0.01

2.24404\(e-13\)

2.24336\(e-13\)

2.24404\(e-13\)

2.24404\(e-13\)

2.24404\(e-13\)

0.03

5.67546\(e-11\)

5.67546\(e-11\)

5.67546\(e-11\)

5.67546\(e-11\)

5.67546\(e-11\)

0.05

7.58984\(e-10\)

7.58984\(e-10\)

7.58984\(e-10\)

7.58984\(e-10\)

7.58984\(e-10\)

4

0.01

2.52048\(e-13\)

2.52081\(e-13\)

2.52048\(e-13\)

2.52050\(e-13\)

2.52050\(e-13\)

0.03

6.09771\(e-11\)

6.09771\(e-11\)

6.09771\(e-11\)

6.09771\(e-11\)

6.09771\(e-11\)

0.05

7.80430\(e-10\)

7.80430\(e-10\)

7.80430\(e-10\)

7.80430\(e-10\)

7.80430\(e-10\)