Table 3 5-class classification: wastewater without CRP, \(10^{-4} \, \upmu\)g/ml, \(10^{-3} \, \upmu\)g/ml, \(10^{-2} \, \upmu\)g/ml, and \(10^{-1} \, \upmu\)g/ml CRP (+400 nm spectrum). The reported values represent the average performance across 30 repetitions. The best value for each metric, highlighted in bold, corresponds to the single best-performing repetition among all trials.
From: Machine learning comparison for biomarker level estimation in wastewater dynamics monitoring
Model | Accuracy (%) | Precision (%) | Recall (%) | F1 (%) | Specificity (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cubic SVM | 63.3532 | 63.3168 | 63.2059 | 63.2612 | 90.8444 |
Fine Gaussian SVM | 59.3492 | 59.5536 | 59.2146 | 59.3835 | 89.8426 |
Wide NN | 57.4206 | 57.4147 | 57.2792 | 57.3468 | 89.3640 |
Mediumk NN | 55.7738 | 55.7569 | 55.6309 | 55.6937 | 88.9518 |
Fine KNN | 55.9127 | 56.1932 | 55.8686 | 56.0303 | 88.9809 |
Weighted KNN | 54.3294 | 54.5295 | 54.2231 | 54.3757 | 88.5824 |
Cosine KNN | 53.7897 | 53.5448 | 53.6330 | 53.5888 | 88.4496 |
Medium Gaussian SVM | 53.5556 | 56.2935 | 53.4102 | 54.8125 | 88.3999 |
NArrow NN | 51.8254 | 51.8435 | 51.6785 | 51.7607 | 87.9654 |
Bilayered NN | 51.4127 | 51.3504 | 51.2731 | 51.3112 | 87.8609 |
Linear Discriminant | 51.3968 | 50.8151 | 51.1057 | 50.9599 | 87.8571 |
Cubic KNN | 51.1230 | 51.4212 | 50.9866 | 51.2027 | 87.7823 |
Bagged Trees (Ensemble) | 50.7619 | 50.6356 | 50.6067 | 50.6211 | 87.6863 |
Trilayered NN | 50.3611 | 50.2789 | 50.2067 | 50.2425 | 87.5984 |
Medium KNN | 50.1825 | 50.3821 | 50.0457 | 50.2132 | 87.5479 |
Coarse Gaussian SVM | 49.0159 | 51.6679 | 48.7692 | 50.1755 | 87.2443 |
Linear SVM | 48.0595 | 48.5859 | 47.8147 | 48.1967 | 87.0181 |
Fine Tree | 38.0357 | 38.1712 | 37.9857 | 38.0779 | 84.5114 |
RUSBoosted Trees (Ensemble) | 36.9524 | 38.8702 | 36.8793 | 37.8441 | 84.2478 |
Medium Tree | 34.9762 | 37.4039 | 34.8757 | 36.0884 | 83.7449 |
Kernel Naive Bayes | 33.2143 | 35.6113 | 33.1137 | 34.3160 | 83.2970 |
Subspace KNN (Ensemble) | 28.4405 | 32.4879 | 27.8565 | 29.9719 | 81.9716 |
Subspace Discriminant (Ensemble) | 27.7659 | 31.7558 | 27.1160 | 29.1964 | 81.8153 |
Gaussian Naive Bayes | 24.0635 | 32.1147 | 24.3561 | 27.6863 | 81.0744 |
Best result (CSVM) | 64.8810 | 64.8072 | 64.7473 | 64.7773 | 91.2273 |