Table 8 Shannon spectral efficiency (upper bound) values (bps/Hz) for various modulation techniques, water types, and photo-sources at SNR = 30 dB.

From: Performance analysis and optimization of modulation techniques for underwater optical wireless communication in varied aquatic environments

Water Type

Modulation Type

LED-PS channel capacity (bps/Hz) at SNR = 30 dB

LD-PS channel capacity (bps/Hz) at SNR = 30 dB

Pure Seawater

OOK

7.5211

11.1919

PPM

3.6006

5.4351

DPSK

6.0211

9.6785

QPSK

13.0580

20.3851

32-PSK

29.0120

47.2819

64-QAM

31.3818

53.2347

Clear Ocean

OOK

6.7536

10.4192

PPM

3.2175

5.0488

DPSK

5.2636

8.9066

QPSK

11.5337

18.8405

32-PSK

25.2373

43.4235

64-QAM

26.9049

48.6089

Coastal Ocean

OOK

3.6980

7.2698

PPM

1.7018

3.4751

DPSK

2.3764

5.7724

QPSK

5.6102

12.5581

32-PSK

10.9980

27.7722

64-QAM

10.5822

29.9085

Turbid Harbor

OOK

0

0.0004

PPM

0

0.0002

DPSK

0

0.0001

QPSK

0

0.0004

32-PSK

0

0.0006

64-QAM

0

0.0005