Table 1 Summary of methodologies, key features, and limitations in ECG based AI models.
Study | Data | Model | Key Features | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|
Raymond et al.13 | PTB-XL, CPSC-2018 | VGGNet-16 | Utilized identical way of transfer learning with ImageNet weights. | \(\bullet\) Predictions were based solely on 12-lead ECG.\(\bullet\) Model complexity due to high parameter count. |
Eleyan A. et al.16 | MIT-BIH, BIDMC | CNN-LSTM | A hybrid model incorporating Fourier transformation was used for heartbeat classification. | \(\bullet\) Increased computational complexity due to hybrid architecture. \(\bullet\) Single-lead ECG (SL-ECG) was not considered for predictions. |
Annisa D. et al.17 | Lobachevsky University database | CNN-LSTM | CNN was employed for feature extraction, while LSTM handled classification in a hybrid approach. | \(\bullet\) Computational overhead remains a concern. \(\bullet\) Training and testing were performed on identical datasets, limiting SL-ECG prediction. |
Xiangyu Z. et al.18 | CinC-2017 | TCN, ResNet | Temporal Convolutional Network (TCN) was evaluated for time-series ECG analysis. | \(\bullet\) ResNet, used within the model, adds architectural complexity. \(\bullet\) Training and testing relied on the same SL-ECG dataset, demanding high SL-ECG data acquisition. |
Jiwoong K. et al.20 | Private dataset | RNN, LSTM, ResNet-50 | Self-collected SL-ECG dataset was used for model development. | \(\bullet\) High computational demands for the considered models. \(\bullet\) Training and testing were performed exclusively on SL-ECG data only. \(\bullet\) New data collection is resource-intensive and time-consuming. |
Attia Z. et al.23 | Self Collection | CNN | A distinct heart condition was predicted using both 12-lead and SL-ECG data. | \(\bullet\) Lack of evaluation on widely used wearable SL-ECG devices. \(\bullet\) Insufficient analysis of differences between 12-lead and SL-ECG data discrepancies. \(\bullet\) Model sustainability regarding artifact removal and segmentation are lacking. |