Table 6 Mean EC results from algorithms for different datasets (30 runs) for deadline ratio 1.6

From: An optimal workflow scheduling in IoT-fog-cloud system for minimizing time and energy

Reliability ratio

0.92

0.94

0.96

0.98

0.92

0.94

0.96

0.98

 

S workflow(Montage)

EL workflow(Montage)

ASSA

1207

1320

1410

1580

10,000

10,200

10,400

10,600

AO

1240

1392

1480

1660

10,121

10,300

10,510

10,720

PSO

1380

1587

1693

2050

10,490

10,750

10,875

11,160

HHO

1270

1450

1540

1780

10,210

10,410

10,605

10,800

FA

1350

1535

1637

1970

10,400

10,640

10,780

11,070

SSA

1305

1496

1595

1865

10,305

10,525

10,695

10,910

DE-MFO4

1422

1640

1764

2125

10,580

10,835

10,980

11,265

DVFS41

1457

1698

1830

2205

10,695

10,940

11,100

11,364

 

S workflow(Epigenomics)

EL workflow(Epigenomics)

ASSA

1300

1440

1560

1650

11,500

10,700

10,900

11,050

AO

1330

1535

1680

1700

11,620

10,800

11,050

11,145

PSO

1460

1943

2020

2076

12,104

11,275

11,450

11,589

HHO

1370

1612

1770

1798

11,710

10,920

11,130

11,260

FA

1431

1800

1910

1985

11,920

11,180

11,355

11,464

SSA

1390

1700

1860

1890

11,802

11,090

11,240

11,358

DE-MFO4

1505

2005

2130

2180

12,230

11,370

11,560

11,680

DVFS41

1540

2090

2215

2295

12,310

11,485

11,658

11,783

 

S workflow(LIGO)

EL workflow(LIGO)

ASSA

1252

1380

1500

1610

11,100

11,200

11,350

11,550

AO

1290

1490

1590

1700

11,210

11,305

11,448

11,679

PSO

1430

1848

1960

2158

11,650

11,700

11,860

12,155

HHO

1331

1590

1680

1815

11,325

11,400

11,545

11,790

FA

1390

1760

1850

2070

11,547

11,601

11,753

12,020

SSA

1360

1650

1775

1910

11,430

11,497

11,650

11,900

DE-MFO4

1480

1950

2078

2255

11,765

11,810

11,957

12,270

DVFS41

1511

2055

2180

2360

11,870

11,908

12,050

12,387

 

S workflow(SIPTH)

EL workflow(SIPTH)

ASSA

1350

1490

1590

1700

11,800

11,000

11,200

11,350

AO

1370

1595

1712

1802

11,915

11,110

11,310

11,452

PSO

1470

1913

2102

2201

12,360

11,594

11,718

11,870

HHO

1402

1700

1797

1913

12,035

11,246

11,405

11,560

FA

1430

1805

2017

2110

12,250

11,485

11,620

11,773

SSA

1440

1790

1906

2008

12,130

11,363

11,512

11,675

DE-MFO4

1503

2000

2200

2223

12,465

11,700

11,823

11,986

DVFS41

1544

2111

2307

2318

12,580

11,812

11,925

12,050

  1. Significant values are in [bold].