Table 5 The rHV values obtained by the competitive algorithms.
ID | Â | MOGWO | MOMVO | MOSSA | MOSMA | MOPSO | MOIPSO |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
TP1 | Mean | 1.1570E + 00 | 1.1528E + 00 | 1.1852E + 00 | 1.1699E + 00 | 1.1527E + 00 | 1.1456E + 00 |
|  | Std | 4.2081E−03 | 1.4500E−03 | 5.9764E−03 | 1.3939E−02 | 1.8185E−03 | 1.8757E−04 |
TP2 | Mean | 1.1602E + 00 | 1.1787E + 00 | 1.1959E + 00 | 1.1685E + 00 | 1.2803E + 00 | 1.1663E + 00 |
|  | Std | 8.3879E−03 | 4.4029E−02 | 2.3095E−02 | 8.2137E−03 | 3.5125E−02 | 8.4971E−03 |
TP3 | Mean | 1.8680E + 00 | 1.9003E + 00 | 1.9881E + 00 | 1.8588E + 00 | 1.8851E + 00 | 1.8529E + 00 |
|  | Std | 7.1853E−03 | 8.5067E−03 | 6.4983E−02 | 8.3678E−04 | 4.4464E−02 | 5.6354E−04 |
TP4 | Mean | 1.1545E + 00 | 1.1518E + 00 | 1.1846E + 00 | 1.1897E + 00 | 1.1525E + 00 | 1.1454E + 00 |
|  | Std | 3.8022E−03 | 1.8115E−03 | 6.6763E−03 | 2.2729E−02 | 2.4537E−03 | 1.5926E−04 |
TP5 | Mean | 1.1578E + 00 | 1.1612E + 00 | 1.1757E + 00 | 1.1551E + 00 | 1.1508E + 00 | 1.1454E + 00 |
|  | Std | 5.8143E−03 | 1.9751E−03 | 4.0478E−03 | 7.4899E−03 | 4.2216E−03 | 1.0910E−04 |
TP6 | Mean | 2.3868E + 00 | 2.4601E + 00 | 2.9926E + 00 | 2.4230E + 00 | 2.4344E + 00 | 2.3739E + 00 |
|  | Std | 7.3031E−03 | 2.4587E−01 | 1.8237E + 00 | 6.8788E−02 | 2.6480E−02 | 1.5502E−03 |
TP7 | Mean | 7.7826E−02 | 8.2614E−02 | 8.3504E−02 | 8.3998E−02 | 9.5610E−02 | 7.9041E−02 |
|  | Std | 1.4243E−04 | 2.6569E−03 | 1.3806E−03 | 7.1764E−04 | 2.4528E−02 | 2.9242E−03 |
TP8 | Mean | 6.8968E−02 | 6.9152E−02 | 6.9330E−02 | 6.9861E−02 | 7.7308E−02 | 6.8879E−02 |
|  | Std | 3.9694E−05 | 4.9654E−05 | 8.2215E−05 | 5.2233E−04 | 2.1392E−02 | 1.7268E−05 |
TP9 | Mean | 6.3888E−01 | 6.5197E−01 | 6.4724E−01 | 8.7813E−01 | 6.3846E−01 | 6.3558E−01 |
|  | Std | 3.3641E−03 | 5.4462E−02 | 7.6354E−03 | 1.4489E−01 | 2.8035E−03 | 1.2665E−04 |
TP10 | Mean | 5.4336E−02 | 5.4495E−02 | 5.4640E−02 | 5.4549E−02 | 5.5037E−02 | 5.4247E−02 |
|  | Std | 3.6199E−05 | 4.0563E−05 | 6.9886E−05 | 4.1626E−04 | 1.5270E−03 | 7.2067E−06 |
TP11 | Mean | 4.1292E−01 | 3.6776E−01 | 3.6411E−01 | 3.2889E−01 | 3.9861E−01 | 3.5143E−01 |
|  | Std | 3.0093E−02 | 3.5211E−02 | 3.6077E−02 | 3.3862E−02 | 4.9353E−02 | 9.8215E−03 |
TP12 | Mean | 2.7049E−01 | 2.5046E−01 | 2.5118E−01 | 2.2766E−01 | 2.7181E−01 | 2.3924E−01 |
|  | Std | 1.4374E−02 | 1.9206E−02 | 2.1430E−02 | 2.7284E−02 | 3.9512E−02 | 4.2977E−03 |
TP13 | Mean | 1.1655E + 00 | 1.1501E + 00 | 1.2183E + 00 | -7.2895E−02 | 4.4915E−01 | 1.1519E + 00 |
|  | Std | 2.7001E−02 | 7.8964E−04 | 1.0608E−01 | 4.0785E−02 | 4.5621E + 00 | 1.4503E−02 |
TP14 | Mean | 3.7261E−01 | 3.5471E−01 | 3.5378E−01 | 3.3909E−01 | 3.8481E−01 | 3.4739E−01 |
|  | Std | 2.8360E−02 | 3.2546E−02 | 3.0049E−02 | 2.6671E−02 | 8.0526E−02 | 1.2268E−02 |
TP15 | Mean | 2.5106E−01 | 2.4897E−01 | 2.4229E−01 | 2.2181E−01 | 2.4829E−01 | 2.3403E−01 |
|  | Std | 9.1150E−03 | 1.4895E−02 | 1.9800E−02 | 2.5702E−02 | 2.3067E−02 | 4.6928E−03 |
TP16 | Mean | 7.7788E−02 | 8.3715E−02 | 8.3578E−02 | 8.3793E−02 | 1.2745E−01 | 7.7721E−02 |
|  | Std | 2.0296E−05 | 2.7118E−03 | 2.2878E−03 | 6.3767E−04 | 1.2644E−01 | 1.3618E−05 |
TP17 | Mean | 6.8965E−02 | 6.9178E−02 | 6.9369E−02 | 6.9787E−02 | 8.5111E−02 | 6.8883E−02 |
|  | Std | 3.3408E−05 | 6.8952E−05 | 1.0279E−04 | 3.1088E−04 | 3.5404E−02 | 1.4803E−05 |
TP18 | Mean | 6.3956E−01 | 6.3957E−01 | 6.5233E−01 | 9.2448E−01 | 6.3918E−01 | 6.3559E−01 |
|  | Std | 3.0895E−03 | 3.2479E−03 | 8.0959E−03 | 1.4951E−01 | 5.1054E−03 | 1.0329E−04 |
TP19 | Mean | 5.4328E−02 | 5.4508E−02 | 5.4649E−02 | 5.4578E−02 | 5.4584E−02 | 5.4248E−02 |
|  | Std | 2.0207E−05 | 4.1924E−05 | 8.5727E−05 | 5.1561E−04 | 4.7495E−04 | 1.2092E−05 |
TP20 | Mean | 2.6596E−01 | 2.4536E−01 | 2.4589E−01 | 2.2288E−01 | 2.6805E−01 | 2.3916E−01 |
|  | Std | 1.1087E−02 | 1.9432E−02 | 1.6988E−02 | 2.1727E−02 | 3.0021E−02 | 4.3317E−03 |
TP21 | Mean | 2.4994E−01 | 2.4721E−01 | 2.3935E−01 | 2.3285E−01 | 2.5103E−01 | 2.3549E−01 |
|  | Std | 1.0471E−02 | 2.1624E−02 | 1.4942E−02 | 2.4451E−02 | 1.5094E−02 | 5.1365E−03 |
TP22 | Mean | 2.6269E−01 | 2.4000E−01 | 2.4497E−01 | 2.2303E−01 | 2.5204E−01 | 2.3496E−01 |
|  | Std | 1.4045E−02 | 1.6589E−02 | 1.4528E−02 | 2.8151E−02 | 1.5695E−02 | 3.3715E−03 |
TP23 | Mean | 2.6644E−01 | 2.5416E−01 | 2.4113E−01 | 2.2017E−01 | 2.7758E−01 | 2.3498E−01 |
|  | Std | 1.3370E−02 | 1.5939E−02 | 1.0315E−02 | 2.0365E−02 | 3.4474E−02 | 4.1594E−03 |
TP24 | Mean | 2.5805E−01 | 2.4337E−01 | 2.3938E−01 | 2.2101E−01 | 2.5665E−01 | 2.3590E−01 |
|  | Std | 1.1050E−02 | 1.2546E−02 | 1.5220E−02 | 2.5725E−02 | 3.1715E−02 | 3.9984E−03 |
