Table 2 A comparison of performances for this work and other UTC-PDs working on 1550 nm optical source.

From: Modelling and optimization of Ge/GaAs uni-travelling carrier photodiodes

3-dB bandwidth (GHz)

Photocurrent (mA)

Dark current (nA)

Size (µm)

Responsivity (A/W)

Material

Illumination type

References

54 @ -2 V

2.25 @ -2 V

117 @ -2 V

D: 5

0.5

Ge/GaAs

Vertical

This work

9.3 @ -2 V

-

8 @ -1 V

D: 10

0.11

Ge/GaAs

Vertical

20

12.8 @ -1.5 V

-

30,000 @ -2 V

D: 27

0.36

InP

Vertical

33

52.2@ -2 V

-

-

D: 14

0.33

InP

Vertical

58

110 @ -4 V

23 @ -4 V

50 @ -4 V

2 × 25

0.53

InP

Waveguide

45

9.3 @ -5 V

2.5 @ -2 V

1000 @ 0 V

D: 15

0.18

Ge/Si

Vertical

11

18 @ -3 V

20 @ -3 V

8900 @ -2 V

D: 14

0.12

Ge/Si

Vertical

12

40 @ -3 V

1.5 @ -5 V

2000 @ -5 V

4 × 13

0.5

Ge/Si

Waveguide

59