Table 3 Benefit matrix of the TEGM for the central government, local government A and B.

From: The evolutionary mechanism of haze collaborative governance: novel evidence from a tripartite evolutionary game model and a case study in China

Strategy Combinations

Benefit for the central government

Benefit for local government A

Benefit for local government B

(1,1,1)

HCCMAMB

CA + MA

CB + MB

(1,1,0)

CC − MA + FB

CARAδ1WA + MA

δ1QB + δ2GBFB + TB + λB

(1,0,1)

CC − MB + FA

δ1QA + δ2GAFA + TA + λB

CBRBδ1WB + MB

(0,1,1)

HMAMB

CA + MA

CB + MB

(1,0,0)

CC + FA + FB

δ1QA + δ2GAδ1WAFA + λB

δ1QB + δ2GB − δ1WBFB + λB

(0,1,0)

MAFC

CARA − δ1WA + MA

δ1QB + δ2GB + TB + λB

(0,0,1)

MBFC

δ1QA + δ2GA + TA + λB

CBRBδ1WB + MB

(0,0,0)

FC

δ1QA + δ2GAδ1WA + λB

δ1QB + δ2GBδ1WB + λB